Who would have the best theme team...
-
Off the top of my head I'd say the Yankees but as I think about it, they lack the starting pitching. Their Bullpen of course is lights out with Gossage, Mariano and Chapman leading the party.
Offensively they would be tough to beat even without the 99 Babe which we will soon have I'm sure.
Mantle, Gehrig, Judge, Stanton, Lemahue to name a few.
The Dodgers are probably the most obvious choice especially now the Hershiser is out and tomorrow they'll add Gagne to their bullpen. Scherzer, Kershaw, Valenzuela and Hersh make a formidable top 4.
Who are some other teams you think would have the best theme team? Assuming you can pick anyone who played for them at least a full season.
These are not exactly strict rules.
-
Cardinals is pretty good. It’ll be ever better when 99 Pujols drops.
-
@gamergirl991691_xbl said in Who would have the best theme team...:
Cardinals is pretty good. It’ll be ever better when 99 Pujols drops.
Cardinals if we’re not going future stars…
C- Awards Molina
1B- 2nd Half Pujols
2B- POTM Carpenter
3B- Sig Arenado
SS- PS Edman
LF- Awards Musial
CF- POTM O’Neill
RF- Awards WalkerSP- Milestone Gibson
SP- ASG Lynn
SP- Finest Flaherty
SP- Sig Wainwright
SP- MS LesterRP- MS Smith
RP- Sig Miller
RP- AS Reyes
RP- PS Gallegos
RP- Sig Smoltz
RP- Prime Henke
RP- MS SutterBench- PS Edman
Bench- Sig Edmonds
Bench- Awards Torre
Bench- Awards Glaus
Bench- MS BrockThrow FS Gorman in there somewhere if you wish
-
@gamergirl991691_xbl said in Who would have the best theme team...:
Cardinals is pretty good. It’ll be ever better when 99 Pujols drops.
Oh yeah. I'm a Cardinals lifer and can't wait for a Pujols 99. I'm really hoping he will be either the 3rd boss tomorrow or the collection reward on the 19th. His 97 2nd half card is pretty solid, but I'm very eager for his 99.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Who would have the best theme team...:
@gamergirl991691_xbl said in Who would have the best theme team...:
Cardinals is pretty good. It’ll be ever better when 99 Pujols drops.
Oh yeah. I'm a Cardinals lifer and can't wait for a Pujols 99. I'm really hoping he will be either the 3rd boss tomorrow or the collection reward on the 19th. His 97 2nd half card is pretty solid, but I'm very eager for his 99.
it’d be so good if hornsby was still in the game
-
@gamergirl991691_xbl said in Who would have the best theme team...:
@gamergirl991691_xbl said in Who would have the best theme team...:
Cardinals is pretty good. It’ll be ever better when 99 Pujols drops.
Cardinals if we’re not going future stars…
C- Awards Molina
1B- 2nd Half Pujols
2B- POTM Carpenter
3B- Sig Arenado
SS- PS Edman
LF- Awards Musial
CF- POTM O’Neill
RF- Awards WalkerSP- Milestone Gibson
SP- ASG Lynn
SP- Finest Flaherty
SP- Sig Wainwright
SP- MS LesterRP- MS Smith
RP- Sig Miller
RP- AS Reyes
RP- PS Gallegos
RP- Sig Smoltz
RP- Prime Henke
RP- MS SutterBench- PS Edman
Bench- Sig Edmonds
Bench- Awards Torre
Bench- Awards Glaus
Bench- MS BrockThrow FS Gorman in there somewhere if you wish
Oh nice, I was just about to draw one up. Great call with Walker. I always forget to include him. Also, we should be getting a Finest Paul Goldschmidt soon. That pitching staff is lethal, and the lineup is as good as anyone.
I made this post wanting to gush about the Cards but figured I'd try to be objective hahaha, thank you!!!
-
Reds offense is full of legends so that’s a fun one
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Who would have the best theme team...:
Off the top of my head I'd say the Yankees but as I think about it, they lack the starting pitching. Their Bullpen of course is lights out with Gossage, Mariano and Chapman leading the party.
Offensively they would be tough to beat even without the 99 Babe which we will soon have I'm sure.
Mantle, Gehrig, Judge, Stanton, Lemahue to name a few.
The Dodgers are probably the most obvious choice especially now the Hershiser is out and tomorrow they'll add Gagne to their bullpen. Scherzer, Kershaw, Valenzuela and Hersh make a formidable top 4.
Who are some other teams you think would have the best theme team? Assuming you can pick anyone who played for them at least a full season.
These are not exactly strict rules.
As someone using a Dodgers theme team right now, I can say the Dodgers probably have the most ridiculous theme team. The Orioles were fun to use too, forgot they had Vlad and Thome.
-
@cosmic_wonders said in Who would have the best theme team...:
Reds offense is full of legends so that’s a fun one
Good call. I've been smashing the ball with Foster the last few days. And Votto is one of my favorite 1B right now.
Morgan, Foster, Larkin, Votto, Bench (soon to be 99), Griffey Sr, Castellanos, eventually we'll get Jr. Griffey.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Who would have the best theme team...:
@cosmic_wonders said in Who would have the best theme team...:
Reds offense is full of legends so that’s a fun one
Good call. I've been smashing the ball with Foster the last few days. And Votto is one of my favorite 1B right now.
Morgan, Foster, Larkin, Votto, Bench (soon to be 99), Griffey Sr, Castellanos, eventually we'll get Jr. Griffey.
Don’t forget Eric Davis dropped recently too.. they’ve also got to have a Tony Perez dropping soon (89 ovr so far)
Once I saw that Foster in BR and Bench hint I knew it was time for this squad
Joe Morgan has been my favorite card the last two years even on main squad
-
The Red Sox all time team is actually disgusting.
Full rotation, full bullpen, full bench and line up. It's kind of nutty how good they are.
-
@evylshaun_psn said in Who would have the best theme team...:
The Red Sox all time team is actually disgusting.
Full rotation, full bullpen, full bench and line up. It's kind of nutty how good they are.
Kind of sucks without Pedroia though
-
@jeezy-e_psn said in Who would have the best theme team...:
@evylshaun_psn said in Who would have the best theme team...:
The Red Sox all time team is actually disgusting.
Full rotation, full bullpen, full bench and line up. It's kind of nutty how good they are.
Kind of sucks without Pedroia though
I agree although Mookie at 2B isn’t too bad
-
@jeezy-e_psn said in Who would have the best theme team...:
@evylshaun_psn said in Who would have the best theme team...:
The Red Sox all time team is actually disgusting.
Full rotation, full bullpen, full bench and line up. It's kind of nutty how good they are.
Kind of sucks without Pedroia though
I know, I was hoping we'd get another year of him. But Kikè has slotted in there quite nicely.
-
@cosmic_wonders said in Who would have the best theme team...:
@ericulous1_psn said in Who would have the best theme team...:
@cosmic_wonders said in Who would have the best theme team...:
Reds offense is full of legends so that’s a fun one
Good call. I've been smashing the ball with Foster the last few days. And Votto is one of my favorite 1B right now.
Morgan, Foster, Larkin, Votto, Bench (soon to be 99), Griffey Sr, Castellanos, eventually we'll get Jr. Griffey.
Don’t forget Eric Davis dropped recently too.. they’ve also got to have a Tony Perez dropping soon (89 ovr so far)
Once I saw that Foster in BR and Bench hint I knew it was time for this squad
Joe Morgan has been my favorite card the last two years even on main squad
Oh yeah. I knew I was forgetting someone, I love that Eric Davis card. Does everything.
-
A admin locked this topic on Feb 25, 2023, 12:00 AM
5/15