Piazza VS Perez
-
Piazza easily
-
i only use Topps Now Grandal, and the Top Prospect Rutschman, lover their swings and the switch hitting. their defense is also better than piazzas for sure.
-
I've been rocking Pudge since I got him. I have all the other big name catchers but I'm rolling with him. Doesn't have the power some have but its def adequate. And that diamond defense and 70s speed puts him above the rest imo. No need to carry another catcher either because of the good speed and diamond fielding.
-
I do love HRD Salvador Oetez more than ASG and between the two, I prefer Petez though Piazza is a doubles machine.
I'm in the Grandal, Adley, Pudge camp. And don't sleep on Award Posada.
-
I believe in keeping advice to the question asked, so I'll answer:
If you can handle Piazza's swing, then go with him. If you can't, then Perez is a bit safer imo.
WITH THAT BEING SAID: Adley can be acquired free via TA, and would be my personal recommendation over both of them.
-
Adley is that dude.
-
Adley is the best catcher in the game.
Between Perez and Piazza, Piazza is better overall, but Perez is a GREAT bat to have off the bench as a pinch hitter vs lefties.
-
Adley > Posada > everyone else.
-
-
@dbub_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
Grandal. When a catcher is literally one of my 3-4 best hitters, that makes up for other deficiencies.
Grandal is one of a kind - the only player who turns a gapper into a single.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
I do love HRD Salvador Oetez more than ASG and between the two, I prefer Petez though Piazza is a doubles machine.
I'm in the Grandal, Adley, Pudge camp. And don't sleep on Award Posada.
Bro same. I mash with the 95 way better than the 97
-
@lazy_toast_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@ericulous1_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
I do love HRD Salvador Oetez more than ASG and between the two, I prefer Petez though Piazza is a doubles machine.
I'm in the Grandal, Adley, Pudge camp. And don't sleep on Award Posada.
Bro same. I mash with the 95 way better than the 97
Exactly, no idea why but the other day I had trouble with his Topps moment and was thinking, if this were his HRD card, I'd have completed it with 1 swing. Took me like 15 mins for a Rookie level HR.
-
@write2shawn_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@dbub_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
Grandal. When a catcher is literally one of my 3-4 best hitters, that makes up for other deficiencies.
Grandal is one of a kind - the only player who turns a gapper into a single.
I had a legit infield single with him in the event last night. That 4 speed rating at parallel 3 was the difference.
-
@lazy_toast_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@ericulous1_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
I do love HRD Salvador Oetez more than ASG and between the two, I prefer Petez though Piazza is a doubles machine.
I'm in the Grandal, Adley, Pudge camp. And don't sleep on Award Posada.
Bro same. I mash with the 95 way better than the 97
The 95 has better hitting attributes. Almost 120 contact vs righties. That’s why the top players used him in the tournament.
-
@write2shawn_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@dbub_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
Grandal. When a catcher is literally one of my 3-4 best hitters, that makes up for other deficiencies.
Grandal is one of a kind - the only player who turns a gapper into a single.
But he also turns a HR into a HR. His lack of speed is fine trotting around the bases.
-
@dbub_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@write2shawn_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@dbub_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
Grandal. When a catcher is literally one of my 3-4 best hitters, that makes up for other deficiencies.
Grandal is one of a kind - the only player who turns a gapper into a single.
But he also turns a HR into a HR. His lack of speed is fine trotting around the bases.
I agree that Grandal is a good hitter but it’s almost all or nothing with him. He’s basically a liability once he’s on base, He sure as hell isn’t stretching a single into a double. The only time the dude can hit a triple is if the ball gets stuck in the fence.
-
@mrad2010_mlbts said in Piazza VS Perez:
@dbub_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@write2shawn_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@dbub_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
Grandal. When a catcher is literally one of my 3-4 best hitters, that makes up for other deficiencies.
Grandal is one of a kind - the only player who turns a gapper into a single.
But he also turns a HR into a HR. His lack of speed is fine trotting around the bases.
I agree that Grandal is a good hitter but it’s almost all or nothing with him. He’s basically a liability once he’s on base, He sure as hell isn’t stretching a single into a double. The only time the dude can hit a triple is if the ball gets stuck in the fence.
I mean. I hear you. And if you hit almost as well with another catcher, then of course, go with a faster guy.
But when Grandal hits at about .400 higher OPS than any other catcher I've used, then I have no choice but to use him.
-
I love my TA season 3 Perez........Have had him in since i got him and stil haven't taken him out. The guy is a beast hitting and defense is great too. I'm at P4 for him, hopefully i can max him out soon.
-
@dbub_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@mrad2010_mlbts said in Piazza VS Perez:
@dbub_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@write2shawn_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
@dbub_psn said in Piazza VS Perez:
Grandal. When a catcher is literally one of my 3-4 best hitters, that makes up for other deficiencies.
Grandal is one of a kind - the only player who turns a gapper into a single.
But he also turns a HR into a HR. His lack of speed is fine trotting around the bases.
I agree that Grandal is a good hitter but it’s almost all or nothing with him. He’s basically a liability once he’s on base, He sure as hell isn’t stretching a single into a double. The only time the dude can hit a triple is if the ball gets stuck in the fence.
I mean. I hear you. And if you hit almost as well with another catcher, then of course, go with a faster guy.
But when Grandal hits at about .400 higher OPS than any other catcher I've used, then I have no choice but to use him.
True. I was using All Star JT when people were saying he wasnt even a top 3 catcher. I got him to parallel V and ended up hitting 80 plus home runs and .400 plus batting average. I still think he might be the best catcher in the game but Adley is starting to change my mind. Hat Grandal card is really good too. I’ve used him a handful of games. It’s easy to get hits with him more than most catchers.
-
Pudge is the total package imo.
