Pitched same game twice... Back to back...

[victorr1972_XBL]

I play on the xb1 and play for SF. Played LA and pitched to the 8th when i got pinch hit for with about an 80 pitch count. It ended up being a no decision for me as the relief got the win in extra innings.
I advanced the game to next appearance and am playing the same game on the same team with the same record and get the manager tips after 35 pitches (4th inning), that i am getting tired and left in until my pitch counter reached 70 (7th inning), well into no longer having any stamina (pitcher out of stamina tip at 42 pitches), ended up giving up a hit and the reliever gives up 2 additional in the inning and giving me the loss...