we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...
-
@stickball_eugene_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
How about if we are given the option to set two starting lineups, one for a righty, one for a lefty. Then, based on the starting pitcher of the team we get matched with, we automatically use the lineup associated with that handed pitcher. Franchise has something similar. You set four lineups based on pitcher handedness and DH/no DH. Then when playing against computer, it picks the correct lineup. We could use the same type of flexibility in Ranked Seasons.
As noted -- people would just start a reliever to manipulate the line up and bring in their starter afterwards. Then everyone who wants to stack their lineups will complain about people using openers.
Like yeah..I'll start a game with Hader or Chapman to force people to make a stacked vs lefty build then bring in Pedro (or whomever) after 3 batters to stack the odds in my favor.
Offline play -- matters less in terms of the above but you can also dictate who is starting by who you select so just learn the rotations and proceed that way.
-
I really don’t think one lefty one righty line up would be as bad because there isn’t ONE lefty pitcher like there was in MLB 16.
It’s also not as basic and clear cut of an advantage as people make it seem imo. Any advantage you gain from stacking a lineup at the start hurts you later in the game, making pretty easy match ups in high leverage situations that actually matter. Inning after inning.
People won’t have pinch runners for when someone walks whoever before the pitcher because you have Yordan and JD ready to pinch hit or start if the pitcher is whatever hand. Defensive subs will disappear for massive bats leading to more and more gapers against them.
If you want to start a RP every game and change after one inning, your bullpen will be destroyed or you’ll be quitting early taking away any potential comebacks.
Far more strategy to line ups then bringing in a guy to hit for your pitcher when he comes up for me.
-
@charterbus_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
If you want to start a RP every game and change after one inning, your bullpen will be destroyed or you’ll be quitting early taking away any potential comebacks.
Not sure how someone's bullpen would be destroyed by bringing in 1 reliever or why they would quit early? You wouldn't throw RPs all game, you'd bring in a RP then sub in your SP afterwards which would then force the other guy to either mass sub or deal with it. If they mass sub, no PH/PRs later. If they don't , theyre now stuck with all righties (switch hitters obviously immune to this whole thing)
-
@raesone_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
Here's an idea: learn how to hit lefty/lefty and righty/righty. I never hear these complaints coming from the people who can actually hit the ball in this game.
Overall, I agree with you here, but I feel like we should be able to set a vs. R and a vs. L lineup within our roster, and that's that. Choose your pitcher, and skip the lineup screen (how many chances do you need to set a lineup anyway?)
If I have two players on my roster with the intention of platooning, I shouldn't have to burn a pinch hitter just because I find out once the game starts that I guessed the wrong one of the two. I tend to look for mostly balanced players, so I mostly avoid this anyway, but it does take away opportunities to use players I wouldn't necessarily (I'm referring to players with extreme splits)
-
@khain24_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
@stickball_eugene_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
How about if we are given the option to set two starting lineups, one for a righty, one for a lefty. Then, based on the starting pitcher of the team we get matched with, we automatically use the lineup associated with that handed pitcher. Franchise has something similar. You set four lineups based on pitcher handedness and DH/no DH. Then when playing against computer, it picks the correct lineup. We could use the same type of flexibility in Ranked Seasons.
As noted -- people would just start a reliever to manipulate the line up and bring in their starter afterwards. Then everyone who wants to stack their lineups will complain about people using openers.
Like yeah..I'll start a game with Hader or Chapman to force people to make a stacked vs lefty build then bring in Pedro (or whomever) after 3 batters to stack the odds in my favor.
Offline play -- matters less in terms of the above but you can also dictate who is starting by who you select so just learn the rotations and proceed that way.
Gotcha. Thanks. Now I get the bigger problem.
-
@born2bewild007_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
@louieepthree_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
@el-fiama-bianca_xbl said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
No clue why this isn't already a thing. Cause In real life it's not like your opponents lineup is a secret..
All I really care about is the pitcher. Not being able to see their pitcher is ridiculous and can dramatically screw up your game.
For example I have Harper, Griffey, Ohtani, Seager who are all lefties and I start them every game. But if my opponent is starting a LHP, then I wont start all 4 of those guys cause my bench is really deep and I want to be able to play matchups later on in the game if I have to.
But since I cant see my opponents SP, I am forced to either start my lefty batters against a LHP and be at a disadvantage. Or I can put myself in a better position and once the game starts i can substitute in my right handed batters but then I lose those left handed hitters the rest of the game.....
It's absolutely stupid and makes zero sense to not show the pitcher.
Then everyone would start a Reliever..
Warm up their starters and you'll have a Full Lefty Lineup vs a Lefty Starter like Sale.. then people would complain about thatI don't play online. Can you start a reliever? Because you can't in any single player mode.
Yeah I start relievers in Conquest all the time
-
@wiryhooligan22 said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
@raesone_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
Here's an idea: learn how to hit lefty/lefty and righty/righty. I never hear these complaints coming from the people who can actually hit the ball in this game.
Overall, I agree with you here, but I feel like we should be able to set a vs. R and a vs. L lineup within our roster, and that's that. Choose your pitcher, and skip the lineup screen (how many chances do you need to set a lineup anyway?)
If I have two players on my roster with the intention of platooning, I shouldn't have to burn a pinch hitter just because I find out once the game starts that I guessed the wrong one of the two. I tend to look for mostly balanced players, so I mostly avoid this anyway, but it does take away opportunities to use players I wouldn't necessarily (I'm referring to players with extreme splits)
Constructing a balanced line up is a skill in my opinion. There is no need to take that away. Besides, everyone would just start a RHP and then switch to a LHP and vice versa. It's pointless.
-
@raesone_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
@wiryhooligan22 said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
@raesone_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
Here's an idea: learn how to hit lefty/lefty and righty/righty. I never hear these complaints coming from the people who can actually hit the ball in this game.
Overall, I agree with you here, but I feel like we should be able to set a vs. R and a vs. L lineup within our roster, and that's that. Choose your pitcher, and skip the lineup screen (how many chances do you need to set a lineup anyway?)
If I have two players on my roster with the intention of platooning, I shouldn't have to burn a pinch hitter just because I find out once the game starts that I guessed the wrong one of the two. I tend to look for mostly balanced players, so I mostly avoid this anyway, but it does take away opportunities to use players I wouldn't necessarily (I'm referring to players with extreme splits)
Constructing a balanced line up is a skill in my opinion. There is no need to take that away. Besides, everyone would just start a RHP and then switch to a LHP and vice versa. It's pointless.
That’s the sad truth. Whatever measure they do to make cards with uneven splits viable, others will find a way to go against it.
-
no this takes away any advantage you have goin into the game. guys would just start all opp handed hitters. even now when guys will pinch hit right away after 3 innings ill put in a new pitcher who throws with the other hand
-
@el-fiama-bianca_xbl said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
@ch-76-1908_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
Nope. Bad idea
So realism isnt a good idea? Lol ok kid.... sorry you dont understand what playing matchups is in baseball....
Yeah, because Cody Bellinger, Corey Seager, Max Muncy, Joc Pederson (When he was on the Dodgers) never were in the lineup at the same time cause a Lefty was on the hill. There's no Realism in this game when it comes to lineups cause there's no teams with 8LH or 8RH that can all average 40 HRS a season. Learn to hit Lefty on Lefty. And guess what, if you do, you'll have guys frustrated as heck in RS cause it won't matter what pitcher they put out there.
-
why you shouldnt do this is guys would quit, and I mean a lot. im not sure of the way but you can tell when youre home when choosing pitchers and people have quit if theyre not home for royale games etc. I have problems finding games as is with the servers and I can see guys who have spent money with for chipper and such never getting a game due to people quiting.
-
@go4stros25_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
It was like that back in the day but people would make all leftie lineups and back of of the game until they got a RHP.
If they brought it back and made it to wear you grt a loss for backing out there would still be problems. You could easily have 3 switch hitters and 5 lefties in your lineup with
5 righties on the bench to sub in against a left handed starter.This. Although now with 8 relievers an opener is super easy to do then go to a LHP or RHP from the rotation.
-
@khain24_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
@charterbus_psn said in we need to be able to see our opponents lineup before online games...:
If you want to start a RP every game and change after one inning, your bullpen will be destroyed or you’ll be quitting early taking away any potential comebacks.
Not sure how someone's bullpen would be destroyed by bringing in 1 reliever or why they would quit early? You wouldn't throw RPs all game, you'd bring in a RP then sub in your SP afterwards which would then force the other guy to either mass sub or deal with it. If they mass sub, no PH/PRs later. If they don't , theyre now stuck with all righties (switch hitters obviously immune to this whole thing)
A starter entering the game doesn’t get full stamina anymore, even against a bad hitter you’re going to have a tired pitcher in the 4th or 5th inning and need to throw from the BP the rest of the game which is where it would be destroyed for the following games or like I said they can quit and run away to try again.
And I don’t even see you’re argument tbh, everything you said is strategical to me.
Do I do this so he has to do that as a counter? Do I bring in a starter and risk him getting tired, do I let him play like this and try keep the score low so I can dominate him later when he has no pinch hitters, runners, and cant do anything when I bring in my lefty/righty. That’s stuff managers have to think about.
Spamming step out so you don’t get quick pitched with your pitcher, then pinch hit for that pitcher, then warm up a reliever, then bring in that reliever isn’t really strategy it’s just standard 20 iq baseball
-
A admin locked this topic on
