Eddie Mathews HR moment possible?

[Lie-on-Lion]

I'm not the greatest, but I'm no novice at hitting... so is there something wrong with this moment, or hitting in general on rookie? I never play rookie, but on all star, I hit plenty of HR's vs CPU... so why can't I hit one in Eddie Mathews second moment?
Has anyone accomplished this?
I have power swung and had perfect/perfect fly's not even get to the warning track... so i started normal swinging and perfect/perfect does make it to warning track (makes no sense) but still nothing gets far enough to make it over the fence. I feel like it's just a mind game at this point, especially when the difficulty is Rookie. Are these dev behind the scenes just laughing?

[Fatal1500__PSN]

@Lie-on-Lion said in Eddie Mathews HR moment possible?:

I'm not the greatest, but I'm no novice at hitting... so is there something wrong with this moment, or hitting in general on rookie? I never play rookie, but on all star, I hit plenty of HR's vs CPU... so why can't I hit one in Eddie Mathews second moment?
Has anyone accomplished this?
I have power swung and had perfect/perfect fly's not even get to the warning track... so i started normal swinging and perfect/perfect does make it to warning track (makes no sense) but still nothing gets far enough to make it over the fence. I feel like it's just a mind game at this point, especially when the difficulty is Rookie. Are these dev behind the scenes just laughing?

took me like 30 tries to do pudge's. Just keep going man.

[zombiecoleman]

I'm stuck on the tally three hits including a hr in one game. I either get two hits or a homer and a hit. driving me crazy

[Lie-on-Lion]

wow, a good/good power hit makes it out. this system makes no sense to me. A perfect/perfect that just flies out and a good/good that goes yard? oh well... moving on. advice to those doing this objective... dont time it perfectly or you hit it straight (longest part of the field), to pass this, you have to be early or late and find a shorter fence... makes sense in real life i guess... the perfect/perfect thing doesn't