CAP seems to play out of position

[TINSTAAPP_PSN]

I created a Catcher in RTS. My archetype now says he can play SS and in my DD lineup it lists as a secondary position. He looks completely out of position. Brutal animations, botches routine grounders, has almost zero room for error on the throwing meter. Anyone else experience this? Is it a bug? He has 80 fielding and other solid fielding categories.

[joshman21013_PSN]

Same my RTTS position is 2B but in DD the primary is CF and says 2B is a secondary but when I put him at 2B he clearly gets the out of position animations.