Best Players at Each Position?
-
Guys, I just started The Show 20 and wanted to know who the best players are at each position.
If you could please be so kind as to let me know the top 3, at each position, that would be a HUGE help.
Thank you.
-
Catcher- Ivan Rodriguez, Craig biggio, yasmani grandal, CAP
First - babe Ruth, Jose Ramirez, Eric Thames, David Ortiz
Outfield - Mickey mantle, Mike trout awards, ty Cobb, Larry walker, Rickey Henderson, Christian Yelich, Babe Ruth, etc -
@DanTheThriller said in Best Players at Each Position?:
Guys, I just started The Show 20 and wanted to know who the best players are at each position.
If you could please be so kind as to let me know the top 3, at each position, that would be a HUGE help.
Thank you.
Catcher: Diamond Equipment CAP,99 Jimmie Foxx, 99 Piazza
1B: 99 Gehrig, 99 Ruth, 99 Frank Thomas
2B: 99 Honus, 99 Tatis, 99 Hornsby
SS:99 Honus, 99 Tatis, 99 Seager (released on Tuesday)
3B: 99 Foxx, 99 Hornsby, 99 Killebrew
OF: 99 Trout, 99,Mantle, 99 Cobb -
*excluding cap
Catcher: Foxx>Piazza>Posada
1B: Ruth>Gehrig>Thomas
2B: Wagner=Tatis>Hornsby
3B: Foxx>Tatis>Hornsby
SS: Tatis=Wagner>Correa
OF: Mantle>Trout>Walker
SP: Kluber>Hershiser>Kershaw
RP: Gossage>Wagner>Jansen -
@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:
*excluding cap
Catcher: Foxx>Piazza>Posada
1B: Ruth>Gehrig>Thomas
2B: Wagner=Tatis>Hornsby
3B: Foxx>Tatis>Hornsby
OF: Mantle>Trout>Walker
SP: Kluber>Hershiser>Kershaw
RP: Gossage>Wagner>JansenGehrig > Ruth
Trout > Mantle -
@raesONE said in Best Players at Each Position?:
@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:
*excluding cap
Catcher: Foxx>Piazza>Posada
1B: Ruth>Gehrig>Thomas
2B: Wagner=Tatis>Hornsby
3B: Foxx>Tatis>Hornsby
OF: Mantle>Trout>Walker
SP: Kluber>Hershiser>Kershaw
RP: Gossage>Wagner>JansenGehrig > Ruth
Trout > MantleHavent used Gehrig and Trout much, are they really better?
-
@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:
@raesONE said in Best Players at Each Position?:
@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:
*excluding cap
Catcher: Foxx>Piazza>Posada
1B: Ruth>Gehrig>Thomas
2B: Wagner=Tatis>Hornsby
3B: Foxx>Tatis>Hornsby
OF: Mantle>Trout>Walker
SP: Kluber>Hershiser>Kershaw
RP: Gossage>Wagner>JansenGehrig > Ruth
Trout > MantleHavent used Gehrig and Trout much, are they really better?
They are in my opinion, yes. It's all about the swing.
-
Most will say this
1B Ruth
2B Cap or Wagner
SS tatis
3B JRam or chipper
LF trout
CF mantle
RF walker
C FOXX or CAP -
@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:
@raesONE said in Best Players at Each Position?:
@seunguk0317 said in Best Players at Each Position?:
*excluding cap
Catcher: Foxx>Piazza>Posada
1B: Ruth>Gehrig>Thomas
2B: Wagner=Tatis>Hornsby
3B: Foxx>Tatis>Hornsby
OF: Mantle>Trout>Walker
SP: Kluber>Hershiser>Kershaw
RP: Gossage>Wagner>JansenGehrig > Ruth
Trout > MantleHavent used Gehrig and Trout much, are they really better?
gehrig is basically just babe with a different swing, so it''s whichever you prefer, but obviously babe is much easier to get. and i personally think trout is the best player in the game
-
It seems like Gehrig vs. Ruth is the real debate.
-
How about Ted Williams vs. Larry Walker. Is it worth giving up some D for Ted's elite bat?
-
@mwolve87 said in Best Players at Each Position?:
How about Ted Williams vs. Larry Walker. Is it worth giving up some D for Ted's elite bat?
I use Ted as my high leverage vs RHP bat and Prestige Walker as my low leverage (working on Cobb prestige). I would start Walker in right if I had Cobb done. Larry Walkers 99 Arm in right legit plays.
-
C Foxx, Pudge, d’Arnaud
1B Ruth, Gehrig, Musial, Thomas, Foxx
2B Tatis Jr, Hornsby
SS Tatis Jr
3B Foxx, Tatis Jr, Chipper
OF Trout, Mantle, Williams, Ruth, Cobb, Musial, Brock, Walker
P Gibson, Hershiser, Maddux, Kluber, Sale, Seaver
BP Dibble, Wagner, Chapman, McGee, Fingers, Rivera, Crochet, Hoffman, Kimbrel -
C : CAP, Posada, Will Smith, d'Arnaud, Grandal
1B: Gehrig, Ruth, Foxx, Pujols, Thomas, Thames
2B: Jackie, Biggio, Sandberg, Cano, Hornsby, Alomar
SS: Tatis, Wagner, Rollins, Correa, Turner, Mondesi
3B: J-Ram, Chipper, Brett, Donaldson, Matthews
OF: Trout, Mantle, Walker, Cobb, Harper, Snider, Robert, Williams, Brock, Dawson
SP: Kershaw, Maddux, Orel, Gibson, Seaver, Mize, Wood, Sale, Feller, Scherzer, Leiter, Blyleven
L BP: Wagner, Chapman, Crochet, Britton, Franco, McGee
R BP: Goose, Mo, Kenley, Rollie, Davis, Gagne, Dibble -
@Quint75 said in Best Players at Each Position?:
C Foxx, Pudge, d’Arnaud
1B Ruth, Gehrig, Musial, Thomas, Foxx
2B Tatis Jr, Hornsby
SS Tatis Jr
3B Foxx, Tatis Jr, Chipper
OF Trout, Mantle, Williams, Ruth, Cobb, Musial, Brock, Walker
P Gibson, Hershiser, Maddux, Kluber, Sale
BP Dibble, Wagner, Chapman, McGee, Fingers, Rivera, Crochet, Hoffman, KimbrelNot a bad list. But with Kimbrel in there I just can’t take you seriously lol. JK. But seriously no Kimbrel
-
A admin locked this topic on
