Sheff or Biggio?

[MLBTHEJOE_PSN]

Posey has shocked me with how great he hits especially vs. righties. I’m 25,000 stubs away from completing the live series collection and I’m going to try out Biggio behind the dish, because I love 99 Jackie at 2nd base

[raesONE_PSN]

Definitely Biggio

[Quinn2161_PSN]

Biggio but more for the fact that i used trout for a long time as well as doolittle and wagner from collections. Ive used nothing from the NL other than shef.

Shef is the better hitter but biggio being able to play catcher with his speed and gold d is better across the board in my opinion.

[DoIHearBossMusic_PSN]

Sheff >>> Biggio

[olivegarden2_PSN]

Biggio is the best lead off hitter in the game! He also has a better swing. Just ask Mcgunski how good the third leg is

[olivegarden2_PSN]

@Sayjinman said in Sheff or Biggio?:

@mrKoala123 said in Sheff or Biggio?:

@James97M said in Sheff or Biggio?:

Who would you want if you could only get one? I'm thinking about going after one league not sure which yet.

Sheffield is nasty but biggio is my end game catcher you can’t find a better catcher than him imo

I’m torn between putting Biggio at catcher since I got the 99 Jackie. But I got the 99 Posey as well. Posey seems to mash but is so slow. I dunno what to do lol

Put Posey at 1st, Biggio at catcher, and Jackie at 2nd. If you have Papi or Thome then but Jackie at 3rd if you don’t mind the arm...OR if you mind a 75 arm at 3rd but Biggio in left or center and keep Posey at catcher with Jackie at 2nd

[olivegarden2_PSN]

@MLBTHEJOE said in Sheff or Biggio?:

I have 680k in stubs, and another 460k in stubs on investments I could sell. Already have Cole, and Verlander. Is the live series collection still worth it at this point?

Or should I just sell Cole, and Verlander?

Mantle may be the best player all year asides from Griffey so yes, I would do it

[MLBTHEJOE_PSN]

Just finished it. And it feels great. I’ve been burnt out on showdown even thought it’s such a great way to earn xp, packs, bundles, stubs... I haven’t played much ranked this year so I’m going to try that for a while, though I might regret that! Lol. Never made it to WS but I’ll give it a shot

[olivegarden2_PSN]

@MLBTHEJOE said in Sheff or Biggio?:

Just finished it. And it feels great. I’ve been burnt out on showdown even thought it’s such a great way to earn xp, packs, bundles, stubs... I haven’t played much ranked this year so I’m going to try that for a while, though I might regret that! Lol. Never made it to WS but I’ll give it a shot

I’ve never tried to make it to WS. If I was an above average play I would try but I’m average. I’m 18-21 which may be even a little above average because I played a bunch of goons the first week of this game

[MLBTHEJOE_PSN]

Same I’ve never tried to make WS. Am just an average player as well. I only make it to a 600 maybe 700 rating anyways. Only played 14 games total in ranked. But we all know it’s about having fun! And the content released recently has been cool

[olivegarden2_PSN]

@MLBTHEJOE said in Sheff or Biggio?:

Same I’ve never tried to make WS. Am just an average player as well. I only make it to a 600 maybe 700 rating anyways. Only played 14 games total in ranked. But we all know it’s about having fun! And the content released recently has been cool

Ranked isn’t as fun so I don’t play much either. I make pennant race each season to try out the cards or sell for decent stubs. I also do it so if I feel like making a push next season I’m at 400-450 at the start

[Ch-76-1908_PSN]

Sheffield is the best hitter I've used in this game, including Mantle. It's close tho. But mashes RHP and LHP. And don't press vs LHP cuz I lotta people pitch around him with a lefty.
Biggio is a very good card tho and his C availability can come in really handy if you wanna punch run for your C late in the game.

[GoHardGrandpa]

@MLBTHEJOE said in Sheff or Biggio?:

I have 680k in stubs, and another 460k in stubs on investments I could sell. Already have Cole, and Verlander. Is the live series collection still worth it at this point?

Or should I just sell Cole, and Verlander?

You’ve got the stubs, finish the whole live series collection. Get the xp sheff and biggio

[Original_Quad]

@olivegarden2 said in Sheff or Biggio?:

@MLBTHEJOE said in Sheff or Biggio?:

I have 680k in stubs, and another 460k in stubs on investments I could sell. Already have Cole, and Verlander. Is the live series collection still worth it at this point?

Or should I just sell Cole, and Verlander?

Mantle may be the best player all year asides from Griffey so yes, I would do it

Mays is going to better than both of them. Just imagine that endgame outfield with Griffey in left, Mays in center, and Mantle in right. Nothing is dropping.

[olivegarden2_PSN]

@Original_Quad said in Sheff or Biggio?:

@olivegarden2 said in Sheff or Biggio?:

@MLBTHEJOE said in Sheff or Biggio?:

I have 680k in stubs, and another 460k in stubs on investments I could sell. Already have Cole, and Verlander. Is the live series collection still worth it at this point?

Or should I just sell Cole, and Verlander?

Mantle may be the best player all year asides from Griffey so yes, I would do it

Mays is going to better than both of them. Just imagine that endgame outfield with Griffey in left, Mays in center, and Mantle in right. Nothing is dropping.

Mantle is a switch hitter so he is better, Griffey also has the better swing, Mays is 3rd in my opinion

[Original_Quad]

@olivegarden2 said in Sheff or Biggio?:

@Original_Quad said in Sheff or Biggio?:

@olivegarden2 said in Sheff or Biggio?:

@MLBTHEJOE said in Sheff or Biggio?:

I have 680k in stubs, and another 460k in stubs on investments I could sell. Already have Cole, and Verlander. Is the live series collection still worth it at this point?

Or should I just sell Cole, and Verlander?

Mantle may be the best player all year asides from Griffey so yes, I would do it

Mays is going to better than both of them. Just imagine that endgame outfield with Griffey in left, Mays in center, and Mantle in right. Nothing is dropping.

Mantle is a switch hitter so he is better, Griffey also has the better swing, Mays is 3rd in my opinion

Mays had a very compact and quick two handed swing last year, so I don’t think the swing is as issue. Purely on paper Mays will be the best card in the game: 110+ in every hitting attribute, near perfect fielding, 90+ speed and stealing. Plus he gets the special animation on balls over his head. So best fielder in the game, and likely the best stats in the game.

Though as your post makes clear, it’s down to personal preference with swing type and switch hitting. I’ll be playing Ruth over Griffey, for example.