Update 1.11 Discussion
-
This patch made the game much worse. Since the game came out, pretty much every patch has made the game worse. What an absolute failure from SDS. We need a new baseball game.
-
Hey homers that are saying it’s great. Tell the truth, you can’t pitch, there are still dumb errors on defense and outfielders at times just half [censored] to the balk allowing extra bases. I have 5 of the best pitchers in the game and they hand at least 2 pitches per at bat during the game. I don’t want a [censored] homerun derby like in br and events. I want a game where you earn runs not hit homeruns for every run scored.
-
Everyone complaining that you can't pitch anymore. Is it possible that you can't just blow fastballs past people that before the patch had no chance of touching them?
I'm not saying pitching isn't flawed, I'm getting hit harder too, but before the patch I had days where you could toss 95mph fastballs right down the middle all game and strike me out 20 times.
I'm not being confrontational, I don't know what the answer is, but half the players being completely helpless against fastballs isn't it.
-
Just had another game where they are hitting non stop home runs, and I can barely hit. Before the patch I was competitive, now I might as well but a blindfold on and hope for the best. Guess I'll have to start up a franchise coz this is a joke
-
Problem with this patch is it destroyed pitching. Timing windows were bad, because they were inconsistent and unforgiving, but the pci size was a non issue in my opinion. I’d love to have seen timing windows opened up just slightly and the PCI left alone, because I think that would have kept the balance pretty even. As it stands, I’m struggling to pitch, which was always the main focus of the game for me. Small sample size and I can’t get out of all star hell, so I’ve not had the chance to play a proper game online yet, this is a very early impression.
My suggestion to improve the state of hitting would have been to open the timing windows slightly (in laggy away games or at some MLB stadiums, it was to difficult to hit the ball pre patch), reduce the amount of weakly hit good/okay on swings that had good timing and the PCI on the ball and maybe even reduce the PCI size slightly as a trade off.
It sounds counter intuitive initially, especially when the patch is designed to make hitting easier, but with the swing timing window increase and reduction in good/okay giving rise to more hits anyway, the PCI shrinking (by say 10%?) would have been a fair trade off in my opinion. I’m going to try to get out of this all star madness (tough when you give up so many homers no matter where you try to pitch) and see how the game plays on better settings at HoF, but for now, I think there’s too much emphasis on offence at all star level and pitching is a nightmare. My ERA is 5.85 this season, which is absolutely disgusting. Looking at WS, ERAs are eye popping. Rebel is supposedly the best player in the game, but pitches to a 6.92 ERA. I’m sorry but if you’re giving up seven runs a game, you’re not good. Yeah, he never loses and he hits over .500 in his 12 games this season, but personally if you’re giving up seven runs a game on average, you shouldn’t be the greatest player of all time. Maybe the greatest hitter, but that’s only half the game. There’s people at the top of the leaderboards pitching to 8+. That ain’t right. -
Oh and I filled out the survey, but obviously that was based on the last two months of gameplay. Answers may not apply post 1.11.
-
-
My biggest problem remain pitching! To me is never been that random...doesn't matter if i use analog or meter, a perfect input is not being rewarded!
Balls always tend to go down the middle, and again i played every mlb game and is never been that bad!
I would understand if im using pitchers with bad control, but come on now we have 95 control guys with perfect inputs and the ball goes nowhere near the spot...over and over and over!
I really hope it will be addressed because if its not after 2 months i would think SDS is fine with this and that doesn't make any sense to me... -
https://twitter.com/sweedy1407/status/1261211704370892800?s=21
This keeps happening and it’s really pissing me off. Why are they selecting this animation, taking control of my defender away from me and making the outfielder back off? I keep losing because you’re handing runs to my opponents on this kind of garbage. Not to mention these fantastic
Early/okay home runs that seem prevalent now.
I can’t hit regardless, that’s been a constant for years and I’m over it, that’s just me, but now I can’t pitch, nor can I make routine plays on easy fly balls because the game simply will not allow me to. I mean I can just quit out and hand my opponent a win before a pitch is thrown if that suits the game better, save the trouble of orchestrating all this nonsense and cut to the chase. -
@squishiesgirl said in Update 1.11 Discussion:
@ComebackLogic said in Update 1.11 Discussion:
@Blax345 said in Update 1.11 Discussion:
Lost one game 13-2, he couldn't stop hitting home runs. Hopefully just a one off, coz that won't make for a very fun game anymore
That’s fine, I gave up nine runs in the 8th to lose my last game by four. I couldn’t pitch anywhere that wasn’t yanked out for a homer. I think this patch will be a major boost for directional hitters.
Lol everything always benefits directional hitters with you
LOL feel free to check my post history for the many, many posts where I wax lyrical about directional hitting. Think you’ve got me confused with someone else.
-
@ComebackLogic said in Update 1.11 Discussion:
https://twitter.com/sweedy1407/status/1261211704370892800?s=21
This keeps happening and it’s really pissing me off. Why are they selecting this animation, taking control of my defender away from me and making the outfielder back off? I keep losing because you’re handing runs to my opponents on this kind of garbage. Not to mention these fantastic
Early/okay home runs that seem prevalent now.
I can’t hit regardless, that’s been a constant for years and I’m over it, that’s just me, but now I can’t pitch, nor can I make routine plays on easy fly balls because the game simply will not allow me to. I mean I can just quit out and hand my opponent a win before a pitch is thrown if that suits the game better, save the trouble of orchestrating all this nonsense and cut to the chase.https://twitter.com/baseball_lol/status/1261196544776142848?s=19 view these
-
@JChilds213 Oh, I’ve seen it all and then some. This is definitely the most broken version of MLB the Show ever, yet somehow it’s still better than ‘18. I think that’s only down to the content at this point though, ‘18 had the most horrific content I’ve ever seen in a video game in my life. I just can’t fathom why we have such random animations being selected by the defense, players running through solid objects, boundaries incorrectly defined, swing feedback is insane, I can hit a fastball late for a fly ball to extreme RF with a righty and get Good/Good feedback, yet put a fastball directly in the centre of the PCI with good timing and get a negative exit velo and Good/Okay feedback. Early swings are better than good swings, late swings are often better than good swings, perfect/perfect is a random indicator for success, with no guarantees of reward for doing everything optimally, defending against bunting is a mess, desync is as bad as I’ve ever seen it and the game is just a home run derby simulator at this point in time.
-
Have played 2 RS games so far and I must say hitting is far to forgiving now. I’ve noticed both myself & my opponents getting more ticky tacky hits. Both games i was able to score 10+ runs in when before I’d average more around 4-8. Imo you took the skill gap out and now games are going to be slugfests especially with how pitching is right now.
-
@ComebackLogic said in Update 1.11 Discussion:
@squishiesgirl said in Update 1.11 Discussion:
@ComebackLogic said in Update 1.11 Discussion:
@Blax345 said in Update 1.11 Discussion:
Lost one game 13-2, he couldn't stop hitting home runs. Hopefully just a one off, coz that won't make for a very fun game anymore
That’s fine, I gave up nine runs in the 8th to lose my last game by four. I couldn’t pitch anywhere that wasn’t yanked out for a homer. I think this patch will be a major boost for directional hitters.
Lol everything always benefits directional hitters with you
LOL feel free to check my post history for the many, many posts where I wax lyrical about directional hitting. Think you’ve got me confused with someone else.
Eh maybe...don't really care enough to check. either way
-
Exit velocities are slower for me. Contact is more consistent but now the majority of my contact is good ok regardless of where the ball seems to be in the pci. Are the rest of you crushing the ball now?
-
I really hope this patch doesnt stick around long. Making batting easier doesnt fix the skill gap at all. It just makes the game a coin flip of who breaks the opposing pitchers confidence first. What's wrong with a fair competitive game. I don't want to be rewarded for bad timing or mediocre placement. quit trying to let everyone get a trophy. Obviously this is just my opinion. Hopefully I'm not the minority.
-
@K_Rich57 said in Update 1.11 Discussion:
I really hope this patch doesnt stick around long. Making batting easier doesnt fix the skill gap at all. It just makes the game a coin flip of who breaks the opposing pitchers confidence first. What's wrong with a fair competitive game. I don't want to be rewarded for bad timing or mediocre placement. quit trying to let everyone get a trophy. Obviously this is just my opinion. Hopefully I'm not the minority.
Sounds like they want everyone to be competitive to get more money coming in ... Sports games shouldn't be that way, it should be skilled based, of course you expect some sim aspects and can accept that, but mostly skilled based...
-
I get Network error every time I play online WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
Hard wire or get better Internet...
-
Just an example. https://twitter.com/harrisville318/status/1257847512335032327?s=09
