Same thing is happening to me as well. I just read that if you exit out of the game completely on your console then log back in it should be good to go. I am at work now so I will try when I get home.
Edit: I'll see if I can do it via remote play and keep you updated.
That would be a very collectible misprint right there if this were real card collecting. Would be cool if you could “buy them up” before they got discontinued or “fixed” and have a rare treasure to sell for many Stubbs later 🙂