Depends on your Fielding controls, right?
I have it on something simple, I think it's called "Buttons", where I normally just press B to throw to 1st. If it shows the crosshairs, you need to aim with the thumbstick and then press RT to throw the ball. This happens a lot when pitching or playing in the infield.
S
scottj63_MLBTS
@scottj63_MLBTS