Trfatboy's logic is, "I don't care about this stuff, so it's dumb that you care about it."
It'd be a real shame if this was the typical mindset at SDS. At the end of the day, we all love baseball, and MLB The Show is the one MLB video game we have. SDS should strive to make it as enjoyable as possible for every baseball fan that plays it.
The fans that are already 100% satisfied with it, God bless them, I'm happy they enjoy Diamond Dynasty so much, but the typical offline player also matters and it doesn't take much to satisfy us too. It might not make money right away for the company, but in the bigger picture: the better the offline play is, the better the overall sales will become.
But even money aside, video game developers should have the same kind of pride in their games like chefs have in their food. We don't only pay money to play but we dedicate hours and hours of our lives to this product you put out... SDS should want it to be as perfect as they can possibly make it. And if we're asking for too much, the least they could do is be transparent about what they're capable of delivering instead of constantly leaving their paying customers in the dark.