@charterbus_psn said in Wouldn't 'guess pitch' add more strategy to the competitive game?:
I find this funny because the only professional baseball player I know thinks it’s actually a very important piece of the puzzle to hitting and should be in the game.
When you hit a HR in the MLB, you don’t get to guess wrong, you need to guess the pitch, the location, and put a great swing on it. If you don’t, you aren’t hitting a HR.
The problem is it tells you exactly where the pitch is going when it should just add a small amount of exit velo and hit chance. It’s realistic but not in the way it’s designed.
This game itself is far from baseball. You don’t get to know exactly what degree of launch angle you missed by during an at bat, or the amount of milliseconds behind or ahead you were….. yet if they take that away and became more realistic people would complain.
People want the easy game not the realistic one even if they pretend the opposite.
But you can already guess the pitch. If you think you've figured out the pitchers tendencies or patterns, just put the PCI where you think the next pitch is going and, like you said, "put a great swing on it". There's no need for a separate system.
If you're thinking the game better than your opponent, then you're going to put more outcome in your favor. That is if there is no comeback code 😉
And plenty of MLBers can sit fastball and adjust to off speed.