*New Legends Wishlist for 2025*
-
If you can only pick one name per team, who would be your most wanted Legend additions for 2025?
It could be just be a personal favorite player and not an all-time great.
Baltimore: Brady Anderson
Boston: Nomar Garciaparra
NYY: Hideki Matsui
Tampa Bay: Carl Crawford
Toronto: Dave StiebCWS: Magglio Ordóñez
Cleveland: Travis Hafner
Detroit: Cecil Fielder
Kansas City: David Cone
Minnesota: Chuck KnobluachHouston: Carlos Beltran
LAA: Francisco Rodriguez
Oakland: Barry Zito
Seattle: Ichiro Suzuki
Texas: Juan GonzalezAtlanta: Andruw Jones
Miami: Kevin Brown
NYM: Daryl Strawberry
Philadelphia: Curt Schilling
Washington: Moises AlouCHC: Mark Grace
Cincinnati: Norm Charlton
Milwaukee: Ben Sheets
Pittsburgh: Barry Bonds
St. Louis: Scott RolenArizona: Byung-Hyun Kim
Colorado: Andrés Galarraga
LAD: Hideo Nomo
San Diego: Ken Caminiti
San Francisco: Tim Lincecum -
Much as I as a Giants fan hate to say it, but Barry Bonds has to be the Giants rep. Would love Tim to be there, of course, but Barry was committed to the Giants. Two reasons were his dad, Bobby Bonds, and his godfather, Willie Mays.
-
@beatlesnews_PSN said in *New Legends Wishlist for 2025*:
Much as I as a Giants fan hate to say it, but Barry Bonds has to be the Giants rep. Would love Tim to be there, of course, but Barry was committed to the Giants. Two reasons were his dad, Bobby Bonds, and his godfather, Willie Mays.
I totally get it. Me personally, I didn't really have a favorite for Pittsburgh - apologies to all the Andy Van Slyke fans - so figured I could use Bonds there to free up the SF slot.
Think it's either going to be him or A-Rod getting revealed at the end of the Legends trailer in a few weeks.
-
Please no Curt Schilling for the Phillies, needs to be someone else but not Mike Schmidt
-
Jose Bautista
-
@SakAttack87_PSN said in *New Legends Wishlist for 2025*:
@beatlesnews_PSN said in *New Legends Wishlist for 2025*:
Much as I as a Giants fan hate to say it, but Barry Bonds has to be the Giants rep. Would love Tim to be there, of course, but Barry was committed to the Giants. Two reasons were his dad, Bobby Bonds, and his godfather, Willie Mays.
I totally get it. Me personally, I didn't really have a favorite for Pittsburgh - apologies to all the Andy Van Slyke fans - so figured I could use Bonds there to free up the SF slot.
Think it's either going to be him or A-Rod getting revealed at the end of the Legends trailer in a few weeks.
How about Mitch Williams?
-
Robin ventura
Plus he's be eligible on lad, Mets, nyy, cws if they allow that with boosts next year
-
I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that we get a bunch of new legends. Given that MLB 25 won't be on Game Pass, I'm thinking that SDS is banking on a lot of new "paid" versions this year. So, they need to entice people to buy.
That's my "tin foil hat" post for 25. They announced Manny and Clemens relatively early. So... I'm hoping for some big names to come.
-
For the Athletics (there is no more Oakland, finally): my heart wants Carney Lansford, but I’d be thrilled with Tim Hudson.
-
I think for the A's it's gotta be someone from the Moneyball squad like Hudson/Zito/Tejada or Canseco.
-
@SakAttack87_PSN, I like those guys, too... Canseco isn't a Moneyball guy, though
-
@The_Joneser_PSN said in *New Legends Wishlist for 2025*:
@SakAttack87_PSN, I like those guys, too... Canseco isn't a Moneyball guy, though
Oh, I'm aware I was saying I would take any of those three Moneyball guys or someone like Canseco. That Milestone 40/40 card would be fun.
-
@SakAttack87_PSN said in *New Legends Wishlist for 2025*:
@SakAttack87_PSN said in *New Legends Wishlist for 2025*:
@beatlesnews_PSN said in *New Legends Wishlist for 2025*:
Much as I as a Giants fan hate to say it, but Barry Bonds has to be the Giants rep. Would love Tim to be there, of course, but Barry was committed to the Giants. Two reasons were his dad, Bobby Bonds, and his godfather, Willie Mays.
I totally get it. Me personally, I didn't really have a favorite for Pittsburgh - apologies to all the Andy Van Slyke fans - so figured I could use Bonds there to free up the SF slot.
Think it's either going to be him or A-Rod getting revealed at the end of the Legends trailer in a few weeks.
How about Mitch Williams?
I thank him every day for throwing that pitch to Will Clark that Clark hit at Candlestick that year, too. I tried to heckle him at 'The Stick the next season and his response said he didn't like it.
-
@MarioMendoza935_XBL said in *New Legends Wishlist for 2025*:
I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that we get a bunch of new legends. Given that MLB 25 won't be on Game Pass, I'm thinking that SDS is banking on a lot of new "paid" versions this year. So, they need to entice people to buy.
That's my "tin foil hat" post for 25. They announced Manny and Clemens relatively early. So... I'm hoping for some big names to come.
I was surprised they announced Clemens so soon. If I was in charge, I would have just announced Manny and saved Clemens for the climax. Which means whoever they're keeping quiet is a biggie. I'm guessing one of them won't be Nomar since they already announced two Red Sox players, though I'd love that (just don't make him a Dodger).
-
Agreed. The fact that they dropped Manny and Clemens already makes you think they have a pretty big reveal left for the official Legends trailer.
Those two have been major requests for years now so the fact that neither is the main event makes it hard not to get excited.
-
Yankees: Strawberry
Orioles: Brady Anderson
Red Sox: Laser Show
Blue Jays: Joey Bats
Rays: CansecoTigers: Gibson
Twins: Puckett
Guardians: Lofton
Royals: Bo
White Sox: OrdonezAngels: K-Rod
A’s: Zito
Rangers: A-Rod
Mariners: Ichiro
Astros: BeltranMets: Doc
Braves: Teixiera
Nationals: Papelbon
Phillies: Rose
Marlins: BeckettPirates: Bonds
Reds: Ron Gant
Brewers: Nomo
Cardinals: Isringhausen
Cubs: NomarGiants: Lincecum
Dodgers: Koufax
D-Backs: Schilling
Rockies: Burks
Padres: GilesI took some liberties with “team they played for” but I like this list
-
@SakAttack87_PSN said in *New Legends Wishlist for 2025*:
I think for the A's it's gotta be someone from the Moneyball squad like Hudson/Zito/Tejada or Canseco.
-
Love the idea of Cecil Fielder for Detroit, but also want to add Tony Phillips, Travis Fryman, Tony Clark, Damion Easley, Bobby Higginson...just to name a few. If you want to go the '90s route.
I'd also love to see Lou Whitaker. No reason Sweet Lou shouldn't be a legend.
-
For the Cardinals, there are players I would like before Rolen.
Ted Simmons - With Molina out of the game the catcher choices have been limited.
Chris Carpenter - Other than Bob Gibson there have no legend pitchers for Cardinals.
Willie Mcgee - The only Cardinal MVP winner since 1967 not in the game (not counting Pujols)Obviously I would like PUjols, Wainwright and Molina back but until that point I would take the above.
-
@bostondirtdog21_PSN said in *New Legends Wishlist for 2025*:
Yankees: Strawberry
Orioles: Brady Anderson
Red Sox: Laser Show
Blue Jays: Joey Bats
Rays: CansecoTigers: Gibson
Twins: Puckett
Guardians: Lofton
Royals: Bo
White Sox: OrdonezAngels: K-Rod
A’s: Zito
Rangers: A-Rod
Mariners: Ichiro
Astros: BeltranMets: Doc
Braves: Teixiera
Nationals: Papelbon
Phillies: Rose
Marlins: BeckettPirates: Bonds
Reds: Ron Gant
Brewers: Nomo
Cardinals: Isringhausen
Cubs: NomarGiants: Lincecum
Dodgers: Koufax
D-Backs: Schilling
Rockies: Burks
Padres: GilesI took some liberties with “team they played for” but I like this list
Laser Show?
