Justin Verlander Diamond over Zac Gallen?

[thegypsytaco_MLBTS]

Anyone care to discuss how Verlander went Diamond and Zac Gallen didn’t? Who had the better post season? If i watched it correctly. I could have sworn the Dbacks went further in October and Gallen had some good outings while Verlander was at the house! Had to be a miss on SDS’s part. ‍️

[fubar2k7_PSN]

Performance wise I’ll just use ERA. Verlander had an ERA of 1.47 and Gallen had an ERA of 2.95 so I would say Verlander. Neither of them has a championship so that argument while invalid cannot be used.

[eatyum_PSN]

People going up or down ratings has nothing to do with how their team does/did

[TheGoaler_PSN]

Did you have many Zac '10' Gallens, ready to make stubs?
Verlander does have a championship.

[fubar2k7_PSN]

@TheGoaler said in Justin Verlander Diamond over Zac Gallen?:

Did you have many Zac '10' Gallens, ready to make stubs?
Verlander does have a championship.

Not from the 2023 season. I’m reading between the lines that being in the World Series means Gallen did better. Just like winning the World Series in previous seasons is irrelevant.

[SaveFarris_PSN]

Verlander: 1-1, 2.98 ERA, 14K, 6W
Gallen: 2-3, 4.54 ERA, 24K, 14W

Should Verlander have gone Diamond? Probably not. But Gallen earning it more than Verlander is a non-starter.

[fubar2k7_PSN]

@SaveFarris said in Justin Verlander Diamond over Zac Gallen?:

Verlander: 1-1, 2.98 ERA, 14K, 6W
Gallen: 2-3, 4.54 ERA, 24K, 14W

Should Verlander have gone Diamond? Probably not. But Gallen earning it more than Verlander is a non-starter.

2.95* Lol. But yes you’re right. He shouldn’t have gotten it either but from the 2 it being Verlander is a no brainer.

[sbchamps17_NSW]

Gallen sucked in the Postseason so he does not deserve to be a diamond, but Verlander also doesn't deserve to be a diamond either