I've seen it in offline modes and events but I've just started on the RS grind now that I have a half decent team and wow.
Had a game where I had about 7 good/okay with the ball right in the center or close to enter of the PCI and another few balls (that went for hits) where I had good/okay with the ball completely outside of the PCI.
I'm not expecting a hit everytime the ball is centre of PCI with good timing as that would be silly but what's the point of labels/feedback if it doesnt actually represent the result?
Never noticed it as much since given most my games are 3 inning type games since I started.
Yeah. It’s a thing. Also, as has been pointed out, there’s no way of knowing how accurate the hit feedback actually is.