Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Why/how could the pitcher have an influence on hit outcomes in real baseball. We’re not going down the road of pitchers with special powers to determine hit outcomes are we?
For example: When Mark McGwire barreled up a pitch…did the ball only leave the park with certain pitchers and with other pitchers it stayed in play because of who threw the ball?
-
@toast2thegodz_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Please don’t speak sensible on this forum- i think it gets you banned because I see so little people doing it
How could a perfectly released pitch have an influence on the outcome of a perfectly hit ball? Does the perfect pitch nerf the perfect hit? That wouldn’t make sense….nor does it happen….in real baseball.
-
@parradox-cam_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@toast2thegodz_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Please don’t speak sensible on this forum- i think it gets you banned because I see so little people doing it
How could a perfectly released pitch have an influence on the outcome of a perfectly hit ball? Does the perfect pitch nerf the perfect hit? That wouldn’t make sense….nor does it happen….in real baseball.
There are tons of variables that exist that can be considered why every perfect swing/hit ball is not 100% a HR- if you don’t or can’t understand that then I don’t have the time to explain it to you
Does it happen most of the time with hitters with power? yes. Does it happen 100% of the time? Of course not
-
@toast2thegodz_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Blahblahblah.
ONE HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE POWER.
PERFECT-PERFECT.
Pinpoint perfect pitch shouldn't matter. Unless the wind is blowing in 25 mph, shouldn't matter. Pitcher confidence, HR/9, H/9...shouldn't matter.
So long as SDS stands by competitive mode being "stick skills reign supreme," none of that should matter.
125 power, perfect-perfect is all that should matter.
Just say you don’t watch or never played baseball without actually saying it- at times I do feel a bit sorry for SDS bc of ppl like you
Is the game perfect- no( those diving slides and foul tips need fixing)
But a person made a perfect and correct response to the issue at hand and all you can say is “wahwah 125power P/P should be a HR” lol
SDS said it, not me. Stick skills reign supreme. Or they should. I watch a lot of baseball. Competitive online is NOT "irl baseball." Nor should it be. The randomness needs to be minimized as much as possible, which is why WIND is not allowed in RS, right?
I don't play online much. I don't like it. But any competitive online mode that purports to rely on attributes and stick skills -- and thus is NOT sim, which is a separate mode -- should reward PP 125 power shots every single time.
To be clear, I'm arguing against my instincts and preferences, but logic is logic, and RS is NOT real life baseball.
If it was Clemente, with 80ish power, fine. 125. Case closed.
-
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@toast2thegodz_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Blahblahblah.
ONE HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE POWER.
PERFECT-PERFECT.
Pinpoint perfect pitch shouldn't matter. Unless the wind is blowing in 25 mph, shouldn't matter. Pitcher confidence, HR/9, H/9...shouldn't matter.
So long as SDS stands by competitive mode being "stick skills reign supreme," none of that should matter.
125 power, perfect-perfect is all that should matter.
Just say you don’t watch or never played baseball without actually saying it- at times I do feel a bit sorry for SDS bc of ppl like you
Is the game perfect- no( those diving slides and foul tips need fixing)
But a person made a perfect and correct response to the issue at hand and all you can say is “wahwah 125power P/P should be a HR” lol
SDS said it, not me. Stick skills reign supreme. Or they should. I watch a lot of baseball. Competitive online is NOT "irl baseball." Nor should it be. The randomness needs to be minimized as much as possible, which is why WIND is not allowed in RS, right?
I don't play online much. I don't like it. But any competitive online mode that purports to rely on attributes and stick skills -- and thus is NOT sim, which is a separate mode -- should reward PP 125 power shots every single time.
To be clear, I'm arguing against my instincts and preferences, but logic is logic, and RS is NOT real life baseball.
If it was Clemente, with 80ish power, fine. 125. Case closed.
So the stadium where the ball was hit is 420 dead center- where the ball was caught was deeper than dead center so give or take 440 feet.
Are you saying that every P/P hit ball with a batter with 125 power should automatically go 450 feet or further?
If he would’ve been a tad bit earlier that ball would well went over the wall in a diff area of the park- sometimes it’s a disadvantage to hit the ball to the furthest part of the stadium- and that’s irl and in video games
-
@toast2thegodz_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@toast2thegodz_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Blahblahblah.
ONE HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE POWER.
PERFECT-PERFECT.
Pinpoint perfect pitch shouldn't matter. Unless the wind is blowing in 25 mph, shouldn't matter. Pitcher confidence, HR/9, H/9...shouldn't matter.
So long as SDS stands by competitive mode being "stick skills reign supreme," none of that should matter.
125 power, perfect-perfect is all that should matter.
Just say you don’t watch or never played baseball without actually saying it- at times I do feel a bit sorry for SDS bc of ppl like you
Is the game perfect- no( those diving slides and foul tips need fixing)
But a person made a perfect and correct response to the issue at hand and all you can say is “wahwah 125power P/P should be a HR” lol
SDS said it, not me. Stick skills reign supreme. Or they should. I watch a lot of baseball. Competitive online is NOT "irl baseball." Nor should it be. The randomness needs to be minimized as much as possible, which is why WIND is not allowed in RS, right?
I don't play online much. I don't like it. But any competitive online mode that purports to rely on attributes and stick skills -- and thus is NOT sim, which is a separate mode -- should reward PP 125 power shots every single time.
To be clear, I'm arguing against my instincts and preferences, but logic is logic, and RS is NOT real life baseball.
If it was Clemente, with 80ish power, fine. 125. Case closed.
So the stadium where the ball was hit is 420 dead center- where the ball was caught was deeper than dead center so give or take 440 feet.
Are you saying that every P/P hit ball with a batter with 125 power should automatically go 450 feet or further?
If he would’ve been a tad bit earlier that ball would well went over the wall in a diff area of the park- sometimes it’s a disadvantage to hit the ball to the furthest part of the stadium- and that’s irl and in video games
Good point. In my earlier post I excepted Polo Grounds, and the point in general obtains. So no, if it goes 440 and is caught, whatever.
But on the other hand, what IS "125 power"? That's Babe in his prime, Barry in his prime, Dunn in his prime (power-wise). Fill in the blank. 450 on a PP with legendary maxed power and no wind in competitive mode? I'd sign that.
-
Signing off, all. Apologies if I offended anyone with the "blahblahblah." My position is clear, so anything else said on this by me is just needlessly agitating the drama.
SDS, get your [censored] in order!
-
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@toast2thegodz_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@toast2thegodz_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Blahblahblah.
ONE HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE POWER.
PERFECT-PERFECT.
Pinpoint perfect pitch shouldn't matter. Unless the wind is blowing in 25 mph, shouldn't matter. Pitcher confidence, HR/9, H/9...shouldn't matter.
So long as SDS stands by competitive mode being "stick skills reign supreme," none of that should matter.
125 power, perfect-perfect is all that should matter.
Just say you don’t watch or never played baseball without actually saying it- at times I do feel a bit sorry for SDS bc of ppl like you
Is the game perfect- no( those diving slides and foul tips need fixing)
But a person made a perfect and correct response to the issue at hand and all you can say is “wahwah 125power P/P should be a HR” lol
SDS said it, not me. Stick skills reign supreme. Or they should. I watch a lot of baseball. Competitive online is NOT "irl baseball." Nor should it be. The randomness needs to be minimized as much as possible, which is why WIND is not allowed in RS, right?
I don't play online much. I don't like it. But any competitive online mode that purports to rely on attributes and stick skills -- and thus is NOT sim, which is a separate mode -- should reward PP 125 power shots every single time.
To be clear, I'm arguing against my instincts and preferences, but logic is logic, and RS is NOT real life baseball.
If it was Clemente, with 80ish power, fine. 125. Case closed.
So the stadium where the ball was hit is 420 dead center- where the ball was caught was deeper than dead center so give or take 440 feet.
Are you saying that every P/P hit ball with a batter with 125 power should automatically go 450 feet or further?
If he would’ve been a tad bit earlier that ball would well went over the wall in a diff area of the park- sometimes it’s a disadvantage to hit the ball to the furthest part of the stadium- and that’s irl and in video games
Good point. In my earlier post I excepted Polo Grounds, and the point in general obtains. So no, if it goes 440 and is caught, whatever.
But on the other hand, what IS "125 power"? That's Babe in his prime, Barry in his prime, Dunn in his prime (power-wise). Fill in the blank. 450 on a PP with legendary maxed power and no wind in competitive mode? I'd sign that.
Yea I mean this thread would have been much better if the ball was hit to a different area of the park and didn’t go out or if this was just in a totally different park all together with different measurements
But seeing how the ball traveled about 440 feet and didn’t go out isn’t that uncommon of a thing bc the ball needed to travel 450 feet due to the area of the park the ball was hit to
450 feet HR’s are not super common lol- OP should’ve picked a different stadium because it looked like he was home in that clip so he has no one to blame but himself- a bit of sarcasm there but not really lol. I never played in that stadium a day in my life
-
@parradox-cam_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Why/how could the pitcher have an influence on hit outcomes in real baseball. We’re not going down the road of pitchers with special powers to determine hit outcomes are we?
For example: When Mark McGwire barreled up a pitch…did the ball only leave the park with certain pitchers and with other pitchers it stayed in play because of who threw the ball?
Actually it did, matter who threw the ball otherwise every barreled up pitch McGwire hit would have left the yard but it didnt now did it. Try again.
-
@parradox-cam_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@toast2thegodz_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Please don’t speak sensible on this forum- i think it gets you banned because I see so little people doing it
How could a perfectly released pitch have an influence on the outcome of a perfectly hit ball? Does the perfect pitch nerf the perfect hit? That wouldn’t make sense….nor does it happen….in real baseball.
Yeah it happens all the time in baseball, not every perfect hit in baseball gets hit for a HR or A hit, You ever heard of ERA, Why do some pitchers pitch better and give up less HR's than other players. Not ever perfect hit in MLB is hit out of the park.
-
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@toast2thegodz_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Blahblahblah.
ONE HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE POWER.
PERFECT-PERFECT.
Pinpoint perfect pitch shouldn't matter. Unless the wind is blowing in 25 mph, shouldn't matter. Pitcher confidence, HR/9, H/9...shouldn't matter.
So long as SDS stands by competitive mode being "stick skills reign supreme," none of that should matter.
125 power, perfect-perfect is all that should matter.
Just say you don’t watch or never played baseball without actually saying it- at times I do feel a bit sorry for SDS bc of ppl like you
Is the game perfect- no( those diving slides and foul tips need fixing)
But a person made a perfect and correct response to the issue at hand and all you can say is “wahwah 125power P/P should be a HR” lol
SDS said it, not me. Stick skills reign supreme. Or they should. I watch a lot of baseball. Competitive online is NOT "irl baseball." Nor should it be. The randomness needs to be minimized as much as possible, which is why WIND is not allowed in RS, right?
I don't play online much. I don't like it. But any competitive online mode that purports to rely on attributes and stick skills -- and thus is NOT sim, which is a separate mode -- should reward PP 125 power shots every single time.
To be clear, I'm arguing against my instincts and preferences, but logic is logic, and RS is NOT real life baseball.
If it was Clemente, with 80ish power, fine. 125. Case closed.
I would agree if the user used square button to hit that ball but the user use X.
-
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
Signing off, all. Apologies if I offended anyone with the "blahblahblah." My position is clear, so anything else said on this by me is just needlessly agitating the drama.
SDS, get your [censored] in order!
For the record I was not offended. I do disagree, the user admitted using X if the user squared that up with using square the ball would have and should have been a HR IMO. My case is closed.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
Signing off, all. Apologies if I offended anyone with the "blahblahblah." My position is clear, so anything else said on this by me is just needlessly agitating the drama.
SDS, get your [censored] in order!
For the record I was not offended. I do disagree, the user admitted using X if the user squared that up with using square the ball would have and should have been a HR IMO. My case is closed.
Meanwhile contact swingers are hitting 400ft bombs. Tell me again how the button matters lol
-
@aaronjw76_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
Signing off, all. Apologies if I offended anyone with the "blahblahblah." My position is clear, so anything else said on this by me is just needlessly agitating the drama.
SDS, get your [censored] in order!
For the record I was not offended. I do disagree, the user admitted using X if the user squared that up with using square the ball would have and should have been a HR IMO. My case is closed.
Meanwhile contact swingers are hitting 400ft bombs. Tell me again how the button matters lol
Here what I know, Some players hit HR or well based on there swing that should not be hitting the way they do. We all seen it. Yeah contact swings HR the percentage is to high I agree. I am stating on that atbat and just giving imo why I believe it was not a HR. That is not to say it should not have been a HR. That issue with contact swings I believe is the vision and the PCI being bigger so it is easier to make contact and square up a pitch. With a 100 mph pitch the ball will travel further because the pitcher is providing the power. If contact swing is hitting change ups, Curve Balls and other off speeds pitches for HR yeah that is a problem. in this case with the Field that was chosen and where the ball was hit using X is the most likely reason why the ball was not a HR. Is that reason wrong maybe it is, that is the only conclusion I can make of why it was not a HR. The stadium, the location in the stadium and the choice of the button was X to swing.
-
A admin locked this topic on
