Can someone give me an unbiased review of Mays?
-
Finished the 8th inning boss. Stuck between Mays and Sale. Yeah I know Banks is good but I already have a slew of right handed hitters who are slow. Beside Seager can hold down SS till I get Tatis. So people have said Mays' swing is terrible. Is this true or is it something you just need to adjust to? I sucked with Mookie for the first month I had him but now I can't take him out of the lineup. Thoughts?
-
I had to take him out and I platoon/late game replacement for Rosario. I couldn’t get anything going with him. The defense though was phenomenal
-
Mays for me is AWESOME & my go to card to use playing CF. Fluid quick swing he has helps me catch up to FB's 98+ MPH. There are many more Starting Pitchers better than Sale. I dont like that Sale has a lower HR/9 attribute then several other Startes being Overall 95 to 99 Diamonds.
-
@mubby_33_psn said in Can someone give me an unbiased review of Mays?:
Finished the 8th inning boss. Stuck between Mays and Sale. Yeah I know Banks is good but I already have a slew of right handed hitters who are slow. Beside Seager can hold down SS till I get Tatis. So people have said Mays' swing is terrible. Is this true or is it something you just need to adjust to? I sucked with Mookie for the first month I had him but now I can't take him out of the lineup. Thoughts?
May’s swing is terrible, for some, others love it, I personally hate it. Reviews are tough to give on players because some swings work for people that may not for others. Cutch and Mantle are the two CF’s I use.
-
Thanks guys. Sale does have lackluster stats but his delivery was glitchy last year. Love Mantle again this year and Trout and Griffey have to be coming soon. Hank and O'Neil round out my OF but Acuna still rakes for me. I guess I'll try out Mays and sell if I don't like him. At worse he is a bench bat or defensive replacement.
-
I play offline, so I don't think what I say is definitive, but I was going to sell him after 2 games. Decided to keep him and somehow got his swing down. The speed is amazing for stealing and he's hit 2 opposite field no doubters for me.
Same with Aaron as I never did well with either. It is also cool to have 99 Jackie, Mays, and Hank in the same lineup. -
@thegoaler_psn said in Can someone give me an unbiased review of Mays?:
I play offline, so I don't think what I say is definitive, but I was going to sell him after 2 games. Decided to keep him and somehow got his swing down. The speed is amazing for stealing and he's hit 2 opposite field no doubters for me.
Same with Aaron as I never did well with either. It is also cool to have 99 Jackie, Mays, and Hank in the same lineup.I run an old school lineup and having Mays hit behind Gehrig is amazing. His swing is terrific but does take some getting use to.
Speed and defense are out of this world.
-
A admin locked this topic on
