I had the Nike Alpha Huarache Elite batting gloves and i just unlocked the Jordan Alpha Huarache Elite. I press view on xbox or share button on PS and it brings up the side menu. I go into loadout from there and equip the Jordan gloves. When I go back to the main RTTS screen and selection My Ballplayer, appearance, equipment, batting gloves, It still shows the Nike gloves.
The ballplayer’s custom appearance seems to be broken. Even after making changes, it reverts back to default. You should have the attributes of your new equipment though.