Let's play a game.

[foge011_PSN]

Story
Bill Lee
Shaun Alexander

[Nanthrax_1_PSN]

Ian Desmond
Mario Mendoza
OJ Simpson

[carey_56_PSN]

I’m Canadian so I can’t get a high five, but I’ll guess anyways:

1. Trevor Story
2. Stan Musial
3. Frank Gore

[RingoNeedsMoney]

Trevor story
Vlad Guerrero
Ricky Williams

[Brayplays13]

1.Jesus Sucre
2.Alejandro Kirk
3.Lamar Jackson

[Ikasnu_PSN]

[censored] some people are getting very close haha

[foge011_PSN]

@Ikasnu said in Let's play a game.:

[censored] some people are getting very close haha

What people? Who? I want names

[bmoo44_PSN]

Story, Walker, Williams

[Ikasnu_PSN]

@foge011 said in Let's play a game.:

@Ikasnu said in Let's play a game.:

[censored] some people are getting very close haha

What people? Who? I want names

Study the hints given!

[Son_of_the_Blood]

Story
Rickey Henderson
Ricky williams

[samguenther1987_PSN]

Story
Musial
Tomlinson

[DirtyHarry10_PSN]

Story
Rose
Ricky Williams

[Ikasnu_PSN]

Bump, another hint drops tomorrow!

[Ikasnu_PSN]

Bumping up

[PhatWhiteOwl]

3 would be Rickey Williams.

[Alimathus_PSN]

Trevor Story
Frank Thomas
Rickey Williams

[Chuck_Dizzle29_PSN]

Trevor Story
Frank Thomas
Chris Johnson

[foge011_PSN]

Trevor Story
Mike Lansing
Shaun Alexander

[WillTheThrill_7_PSN]

Trevor Story
Stan Musial
Rickey Williams

[IIJACKINTHBOXII_PSN]

@Alimathus said in Let's play a game.:

Trevor Story
Frank Thomas
Rickey Williams

I'm pretty sure this (^) is it.
If not:
Trevor Story
Frank Thomas "Big Hurt"
Reuben Droughns