WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL
-
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
Replacement level is the same across the league. It doesn't change because a team is good or bad. Cal Ripken Jr won the MVP in 1991 with the 11th best bWAR season of all time. The Orioles that year lost 95 games. You think his stats wouldn't have been as good if he had played for the Pirates or Braves that year instead?
You going to USE MVP that is a voting method and can be bias, glad you said stats and not WAR.
His stats and WAR would have been the same regardless if he played for a last place team or a first place team.
You do not know that for 100 percent, he would have faced different pitching in different ball parks with different teammates. I like to know how you know that 100 percent?
Stop being obtuse. You know that no one is arguing something stupid like that. Fine, for sake of argument IF Cal put up exactly the same stats for a 90+ win team as he did for a 95 loss team, his WAR would have been the same.
The point was that you were wrong that an individuals WAR would be different based on how good or bad his team is. It's based off your peers not the ability of your team. Now I'm sure you'll go off on some tangent and attack another strawman...
-
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
Replacement level is the same across the league. It doesn't change because a team is good or bad. Cal Ripken Jr won the MVP in 1991 with the 11th best bWAR season of all time. The Orioles that year lost 95 games. You think his stats wouldn't have been as good if he had played for the Pirates or Braves that year instead?
You going to USE MVP that is a voting method and can be bias, glad you said stats and not WAR.
His stats and WAR would have been the same regardless if he played for a last place team or a first place team.
You do not know that for 100 percent, he would have faced different pitching in different ball parks with different teammates. I like to know how you know that 100 percent?
Oh lordy.. you have talked yourself in circles and still can't grasp the whole idea behind WAR.
For the third time. It's to compare a player based on the replacement level player of the same time. It doesn't matter what team he plays on. It's irrelevant. It's taking into account wRC+ which is park adjusted. It's taking into account weighted statistics.
It also isn't comparing players to say how they would do in a different era. It's comparing players based on how valuable they were in their's... which is all that matters...
You can't seem to grasp that...Thanks, All speculation, Flawed
Which does not say the value they would have been in another ERA.
-
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
Replacement level is the same across the league. It doesn't change because a team is good or bad. Cal Ripken Jr won the MVP in 1991 with the 11th best bWAR season of all time. The Orioles that year lost 95 games. You think his stats wouldn't have been as good if he had played for the Pirates or Braves that year instead?
You going to USE MVP that is a voting method and can be bias, glad you said stats and not WAR.
His stats and WAR would have been the same regardless if he played for a last place team or a first place team.
You do not know that for 100 percent, he would have faced different pitching in different ball parks with different teammates. I like to know how you know that 100 percent?
Oh lordy.. you have talked yourself in circles and still can't grasp the whole idea behind WAR.
For the third time. It's to compare a player based on the replacement level player of the same time. It doesn't matter what team he plays on. It's irrelevant. It's taking into account wRC+ which is park adjusted. It's taking into account weighted statistics.
It also isn't comparing players to say how they would do in a different era. It's comparing players based on how valuable they were in their's... which is all that matters...
You can't seem to grasp that...Thanks, All speculation
You are dense dude
-
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@SaveFarris said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
By what you believe Joe Morgan is better than Ken Griffey Jr.
Remember that time you complained that WAR didn't compare players against their era?
Joe Morgan put up great all-around numbers with tremendous D at a middle infield position for a 15 year peak during a low period for offenses.
Griffey put up good but not great numbers (considering he was contemporaries w/ McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, etc) with also excellent D but at a less important position for roughly a 10 year peak (with partial injury-plagued seasons stretching for another 5) during arguably the biggest offensive explosion in MLB history.
Morgan should be rated higher than Griffey but not unreasonably so. Which means WAR (100.5 vs 83.8) is a pretty accurate stat despite your protestations.
Is Trout better than Winfield?
Is that serious question? Of course he is.
-
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
Replacement level is the same across the league. It doesn't change because a team is good or bad. Cal Ripken Jr won the MVP in 1991 with the 11th best bWAR season of all time. The Orioles that year lost 95 games. You think his stats wouldn't have been as good if he had played for the Pirates or Braves that year instead?
You going to USE MVP that is a voting method and can be bias, glad you said stats and not WAR.
His stats and WAR would have been the same regardless if he played for a last place team or a first place team.
You do not know that for 100 percent, he would have faced different pitching in different ball parks with different teammates. I like to know how you know that 100 percent?
Oh lordy.. you have talked yourself in circles and still can't grasp the whole idea behind WAR.
For the third time. It's to compare a player based on the replacement level player of the same time. It doesn't matter what team he plays on. It's irrelevant. It's taking into account wRC+ which is park adjusted. It's taking into account weighted statistics.
It also isn't comparing players to say how they would do in a different era. It's comparing players based on how valuable they were in their's... which is all that matters...
You can't seem to grasp that...Thanks, All speculation
You are dense dude
No Realistic
-
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@SaveFarris said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
By what you believe Joe Morgan is better than Ken Griffey Jr.
Remember that time you complained that WAR didn't compare players against their era?
Joe Morgan put up great all-around numbers with tremendous D at a middle infield position for a 15 year peak during a low period for offenses.
Griffey put up good but not great numbers (considering he was contemporaries w/ McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, etc) with also excellent D but at a less important position for roughly a 10 year peak (with partial injury-plagued seasons stretching for another 5) during arguably the biggest offensive explosion in MLB history.
Morgan should be rated higher than Griffey but not unreasonably so. Which means WAR (100.5 vs 83.8) is a pretty accurate stat despite your protestations.
Is Trout better than Winfield?
Is that serious question? Of course he is.
Not According to WAR
-
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@SaveFarris said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
By what you believe Joe Morgan is better than Ken Griffey Jr.
Remember that time you complained that WAR didn't compare players against their era?
Joe Morgan put up great all-around numbers with tremendous D at a middle infield position for a 15 year peak during a low period for offenses.
Griffey put up good but not great numbers (considering he was contemporaries w/ McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, etc) with also excellent D but at a less important position for roughly a 10 year peak (with partial injury-plagued seasons stretching for another 5) during arguably the biggest offensive explosion in MLB history.
Morgan should be rated higher than Griffey but not unreasonably so. Which means WAR (100.5 vs 83.8) is a pretty accurate stat despite your protestations.
Is Trout better than Winfield?
Is that serious question? Of course he is.
Not According to WAR
Wtf are you talking about?? I just proved it.. what are you reading?
You have absolutely zero clue. I'm assuming you can't read now -
I'll post it again...
Yes. Much better.
It took Winfield 22 years to accumulate 59.9 fWAR.It took Trout just over 8 years to accumulate 73.4 fWAR. And he's only 28.
@dbarmonstar
-
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@SaveFarris said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
By what you believe Joe Morgan is better than Ken Griffey Jr.
Remember that time you complained that WAR didn't compare players against their era?
Joe Morgan put up great all-around numbers with tremendous D at a middle infield position for a 15 year peak during a low period for offenses.
Griffey put up good but not great numbers (considering he was contemporaries w/ McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, etc) with also excellent D but at a less important position for roughly a 10 year peak (with partial injury-plagued seasons stretching for another 5) during arguably the biggest offensive explosion in MLB history.
Morgan should be rated higher than Griffey but not unreasonably so. Which means WAR (100.5 vs 83.8) is a pretty accurate stat despite your protestations.
Is Trout better than Winfield?
Is that serious question? Of course he is.
Not According to WAR
Wtf are you talking about?? I just proved it.. what are you reading?
You have absolutely zero clue. I'm assuming you can't read nowTrout is ranked 86 in Career WAR According to Baseball Reference Ozzie Smith has a higher WAR.
-
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
I'll post it again...
Yes. Much better.
It took Winfield 22 years to accumulate 59.9 fWAR.It took Trout just over 8 years to accumulate 73.4 fWAR. And he's only 28.
@dbarmonstar
I agree Trout is better but if you are just going off WAR he is not.
-
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@SaveFarris said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
By what you believe Joe Morgan is better than Ken Griffey Jr.
Remember that time you complained that WAR didn't compare players against their era?
Joe Morgan put up great all-around numbers with tremendous D at a middle infield position for a 15 year peak during a low period for offenses.
Griffey put up good but not great numbers (considering he was contemporaries w/ McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, etc) with also excellent D but at a less important position for roughly a 10 year peak (with partial injury-plagued seasons stretching for another 5) during arguably the biggest offensive explosion in MLB history.
Morgan should be rated higher than Griffey but not unreasonably so. Which means WAR (100.5 vs 83.8) is a pretty accurate stat despite your protestations.
Is Trout better than Winfield?
Is that serious question? Of course he is.
Not According to WAR
Wtf are you talking about?? I just proved it.. what are you reading?
You have absolutely zero clue. I'm assuming you can't read nowTrout is ranked 86 in Career WAR According to Baseball Reference Ozzie Smith has a higher WAR.
In bwar.. correct.
It's cumulative.. do you understand that?
Ozzie Smith got 76.9 WAR in 19 years.. 19 years.. I'll repeat one more time so you understand. 19 years.Trout is at 72.8 in 8 years.. 8....
Do.. you... Understand?
-
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
I'll post it again...
Yes. Much better.
It took Winfield 22 years to accumulate 59.9 fWAR.It took Trout just over 8 years to accumulate 73.4 fWAR. And he's only 28.
@dbarmonstar
I agree Trout is better but if you are just going off WAR he is not.
Ya. He's already past Winfield in 14 less years lol
-
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@SaveFarris said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
By what you believe Joe Morgan is better than Ken Griffey Jr.
Remember that time you complained that WAR didn't compare players against their era?
Joe Morgan put up great all-around numbers with tremendous D at a middle infield position for a 15 year peak during a low period for offenses.
Griffey put up good but not great numbers (considering he was contemporaries w/ McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, etc) with also excellent D but at a less important position for roughly a 10 year peak (with partial injury-plagued seasons stretching for another 5) during arguably the biggest offensive explosion in MLB history.
Morgan should be rated higher than Griffey but not unreasonably so. Which means WAR (100.5 vs 83.8) is a pretty accurate stat despite your protestations.
Is Trout better than Winfield?
Is that serious question? Of course he is.
Not According to WAR
Wtf are you talking about?? I just proved it.. what are you reading?
You have absolutely zero clue. I'm assuming you can't read nowTrout is ranked 86 in Career WAR According to Baseball Reference Ozzie Smith has a higher WAR.
In bwar.. correct.
It's cumulative.. do you understand that?
Ozzie Smith got 76.9 WAR in 19 years.. 19 years.. I'll repeat one more time so you understand. 19 years.Trout is at 72.8 in 8 years.. 8....
Do.. you... Understand?
Yeah by Career at this point Smith WAR is better,
-
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@SaveFarris said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
By what you believe Joe Morgan is better than Ken Griffey Jr.
Remember that time you complained that WAR didn't compare players against their era?
Joe Morgan put up great all-around numbers with tremendous D at a middle infield position for a 15 year peak during a low period for offenses.
Griffey put up good but not great numbers (considering he was contemporaries w/ McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, etc) with also excellent D but at a less important position for roughly a 10 year peak (with partial injury-plagued seasons stretching for another 5) during arguably the biggest offensive explosion in MLB history.
Morgan should be rated higher than Griffey but not unreasonably so. Which means WAR (100.5 vs 83.8) is a pretty accurate stat despite your protestations.
Is Trout better than Winfield?
Is that serious question? Of course he is.
Not According to WAR
Wtf are you talking about?? I just proved it.. what are you reading?
You have absolutely zero clue. I'm assuming you can't read nowTrout is ranked 86 in Career WAR According to Baseball Reference Ozzie Smith has a higher WAR.
In bwar.. correct.
It's cumulative.. do you understand that?
Ozzie Smith got 76.9 WAR in 19 years.. 19 years.. I'll repeat one more time so you understand. 19 years.Trout is at 72.8 in 8 years.. 8....
Do.. you... Understand?
Yeah by Career at this point Smith WAR is better, We can speculate Trout WAR will be better at the end of his career but we can also speculate he could get injured in his career as Griffey did.
-
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@SaveFarris said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
By what you believe Joe Morgan is better than Ken Griffey Jr.
Remember that time you complained that WAR didn't compare players against their era?
Joe Morgan put up great all-around numbers with tremendous D at a middle infield position for a 15 year peak during a low period for offenses.
Griffey put up good but not great numbers (considering he was contemporaries w/ McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, etc) with also excellent D but at a less important position for roughly a 10 year peak (with partial injury-plagued seasons stretching for another 5) during arguably the biggest offensive explosion in MLB history.
Morgan should be rated higher than Griffey but not unreasonably so. Which means WAR (100.5 vs 83.8) is a pretty accurate stat despite your protestations.
Is Trout better than Winfield?
Is that serious question? Of course he is.
Not According to WAR
Wtf are you talking about?? I just proved it.. what are you reading?
You have absolutely zero clue. I'm assuming you can't read nowTrout is ranked 86 in Career WAR According to Baseball Reference Ozzie Smith has a higher WAR.
In bwar.. correct.
It's cumulative.. do you understand that?
Ozzie Smith got 76.9 WAR in 19 years.. 19 years.. I'll repeat one more time so you understand. 19 years.Trout is at 72.8 in 8 years.. 8....
Do.. you... Understand?
Yeah by Career at this point Smith WAR is better,
No he's not!!!! Man you are so dense it's crazy. Smith totalled that amount for all 19 years. All 19!!! Not 8.. trout did almost the same in less than half the time
-
In their first 8 seasons.
Ozzie Smith 30.4 bWAR
Mike Trout 72.8 bWARI honestly don't think you understand what a cumulative stat is
-
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@SaveFarris said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
By what you believe Joe Morgan is better than Ken Griffey Jr.
Remember that time you complained that WAR didn't compare players against their era?
Joe Morgan put up great all-around numbers with tremendous D at a middle infield position for a 15 year peak during a low period for offenses.
Griffey put up good but not great numbers (considering he was contemporaries w/ McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, etc) with also excellent D but at a less important position for roughly a 10 year peak (with partial injury-plagued seasons stretching for another 5) during arguably the biggest offensive explosion in MLB history.
Morgan should be rated higher than Griffey but not unreasonably so. Which means WAR (100.5 vs 83.8) is a pretty accurate stat despite your protestations.
Is Trout better than Winfield?
Is that serious question? Of course he is.
Not According to WAR
Wtf are you talking about?? I just proved it.. what are you reading?
You have absolutely zero clue. I'm assuming you can't read nowTrout is ranked 86 in Career WAR According to Baseball Reference Ozzie Smith has a higher WAR.
In bwar.. correct.
It's cumulative.. do you understand that?
Ozzie Smith got 76.9 WAR in 19 years.. 19 years.. I'll repeat one more time so you understand. 19 years.Trout is at 72.8 in 8 years.. 8....
Do.. you... Understand?
Yeah by Career at this point Smith WAR is better,
No he's not!!!! Man you are so dense it's crazy. Smith totalled that amount for all 19 years. All 19!!! Not 8.. trout did almost the same in less than half the time
Now you you pick and choose how WAR works for you. So now it is who has a high WAR in less years. 19 years is a whole career we will see if Trout plays that long and stays healthy. I am just making my point that the player with a higher war is not always the better player.
-
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dewrock said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@SaveFarris said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
By what you believe Joe Morgan is better than Ken Griffey Jr.
Remember that time you complained that WAR didn't compare players against their era?
Joe Morgan put up great all-around numbers with tremendous D at a middle infield position for a 15 year peak during a low period for offenses.
Griffey put up good but not great numbers (considering he was contemporaries w/ McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, etc) with also excellent D but at a less important position for roughly a 10 year peak (with partial injury-plagued seasons stretching for another 5) during arguably the biggest offensive explosion in MLB history.
Morgan should be rated higher than Griffey but not unreasonably so. Which means WAR (100.5 vs 83.8) is a pretty accurate stat despite your protestations.
Is Trout better than Winfield?
Is that serious question? Of course he is.
Not According to WAR
Wtf are you talking about?? I just proved it.. what are you reading?
You have absolutely zero clue. I'm assuming you can't read nowTrout is ranked 86 in Career WAR According to Baseball Reference Ozzie Smith has a higher WAR.
In bwar.. correct.
It's cumulative.. do you understand that?
Ozzie Smith got 76.9 WAR in 19 years.. 19 years.. I'll repeat one more time so you understand. 19 years.Trout is at 72.8 in 8 years.. 8....
Do.. you... Understand?
Yeah by Career at this point Smith WAR is better,
No he's not!!!! Man you are so dense it's crazy. Smith totalled that amount for all 19 years. All 19!!! Not 8.. trout did almost the same in less than half the time
Now you you pick and choose how WAR works for you. So now it is who has a high WAR in less years. 19 years is a whole career we will see if Trout plays that long and stays healthy. I am just making my point that the player with a higher war is not always the better player.
I'm done. You are too dense to have a conversation with dude. It's painful.
-
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
In their first 8 seasons.
Ozzie Smith 30.4 bWAR
Mike Trout 72.8 bWARI honestly don't think you understand what a cumulative stat is
I said WAR not bWAR. Wins over replacement, Smith is better. you can not deny it is not.
-
@dbarmonstar said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
@Nanthrax_1 said in WAR MOST OVERRATED FORMULA IN BASEBALL:
In their first 8 seasons.
Ozzie Smith 30.4 bWAR
Mike Trout 72.8 bWARI honestly don't think you understand what a cumulative stat is
I said WAR not bWAR. Wins over replacement, Smith is better. you can not deny it is not.
Lol. bWAR is the one you are using. Baseball reference. fWAR is fangraphs..
It's crazy how you can't wrap your head around this
