I've noticed that when I'm playing H2H games my opponent's runners have a base designation beside their players.
Meaning that's the base they're going to try to run to during the play. If its a fast runner usually it's either Third or Home.
What setting is that under Baserunning?
Right now, the only way I'm able to run to a particular base is if I hold the L1 button. And it will only show the next basd available.