Am I the only one?
-
Who actually kind of preferred the season format for players from last few years? Power creep makes DD just like every other sports game team building mode (ultimate team my team etc). I'm seeing very little variety in lineups, as live series and other cool cards quickly become "obsolete". Plus we are already at 97s?
I would love to see ranked revert back , but add more wild cards that have rating requirements. Like instead 1 or 2 wildcards you have to grind for , you get three right off the bat but have to below 90. Then you get another 1 or 2 that are <93 etc.
Or better yet have a separate ranked mode with HARD lineup requirements, not the overall limit that is easily manipulated: 2 players <99, 4 players <95 , 6 players <90, etc etc
Something please.
-
@nasty6669_PSN said in Am I the only one?:
Who actually kind of preferred the season format for players from last few years? Power creep makes DD just like every other sports game team building mode (ultimate team my team etc). I'm seeing very little variety in lineups, as live series and other cool cards quickly become "obsolete". Plus we are already at 97s?
I would love to see ranked revert back , but add more wild cards that have rating requirements. Like instead 1 or 2 wildcards you have to grind for , you get three right off the bat but have to below 90. Then you get another 1 or 2 that are <93 etc.
Or better yet have a separate ranked mode with HARD lineup requirements, not the overall limit that is easily manipulated: 2 players <99, 4 players <95 , 6 players <90, etc etc
Something please.
I think 2023's model was far superior to 2024, with cards having a long shelf life due to being good for two seasons. 2024 had the awkward period when we were stuck with only OoP cards.
But lets face it, power creep is far better for pack sales. And people like it better.
I just know offline play was by a large margin better in 2023 than 2024-2025. Inning absolutely suck [censored] from an offline content perspective, but thats more due to the TA changes I guess.
They absolutely should have some kind of mode similar to a salary cap but so people couldnt manipulate it with relievers and swapping out starters. That would solve the problems people have with 'fodder' cards
-
@Teak2112_MLBTS The "fodder" cards in the show are so much better than other games. Rookie cards, veteran, last ride and all that. There needs to be more uses for these cards
-
@nasty6669_PSN said in Am I the only one?:
@Teak2112_MLBTS The "fodder" cards in the show are so much better than other games. Rookie cards, veteran, last ride and all that. There needs to be more uses for these cards
I don't disagree.
I play with Topps Now more than any other card type personally -
@nasty6669_PSN I definitely preferred last year. Not necessarily because of seasons. I had way more fun trying different players with all the captain variations. There feels like a lot less variety this year unless you’re willing to use sub optimal choices.
-
Having access to ALL cards and not locked out by seasons is WAY better!
-
I always felt Seasons kept content more organized and gave the game a good pace. However, using whatever cards you like is always better. Then again, instead of the big boss collections, now you have these small but very expensive collections. SDS takes advantage of the smaller collections for Stub profits because the cards are so expensive. The power creep is better, but SDS apparently forgot how to release good content this year.
-
SDS could you change it so that cards over 95 would still still count towards theme team total, just not get attribute boost?
-
@MrNintendo_MLBTS At the very least. 97’s should be getting the boost at this point. That should be updated every inning. Captains are awful this year.
-
Seasons were dumb. I actually quit in month 3 and I believe everyone else did too. They have the data. They significantly lost all users in month 3 due to their collection BS
I imagine they’re going to see a huge drop off after 7/11. Especially after their lazy Braves shenanigans.
Unless you’re a Braves fan you have 0 incentive to do anything and it’s about to get even worse with all star program.
Season typically ends at all star. All of the work you’ve done to P5 etc is completely wasted as you replace your team with new substandard [censored] cards.
-
@TheBigPapa55_PSN said in Am I the only one?:
I always felt Seasons kept content more organized and gave the game a good pace. However, using whatever cards you like is always better. Then again, instead of the big boss collections, now you have these small but very expensive collections. SDS takes advantage of the smaller collections for Stub profits because the cards are so expensive. The power creep is better, but SDS apparently forgot how to release good content this year.
First thing people need to absolutely understand: sets is expiring cards. Seasons is just a longer innings that have NOTHING to do with expiring cards. 2K25 calls it seasons and they have no expiring cards
They need to go back to seasons (not sets as the playerbase mostly hates that). Innings suck compared to seasons. The bosses are 'fine' at best. The rewards along the path are [censored]. the wheel spins are [censored]. No offline content at release is [censored]. The way seasons timed up with TA drops was great. Now its timed up with two things that are realistically the culmination of the prior inning with lightning card and WC, which just feels weird. And neither of those come with offline content like TA did in years past.
-
@JenkinMeyer_PSN said in Am I the only one?:
They significantly lost all users in month 3 due to their collection BS
I suspect they will lose far more people due to collections this year.
At least in 2023 collections could be 100%, or nearly 100%, earned without stubs.
Stubs were there if you wanted to bypass certain things like BR, Events, or a particular program you didn't want to doAt least they stopped the 'special insert'. That is what 2K does, they will make some cards ultra rare within their own tier. At least The Show is upfront about it though.
-
3 Braves and Bobby grich. Tell me you’re excited. No one is. They see chipper and move on.
And also, Chipper is one of the worst defensive players of all time. Hit it to chipper used to be our chant. Also allegedly hit his wife. He’s a switch hitter that’s all that matters. He’s a [censored] person and a [censored] card.
Our other chant was Larry Wayne.
Red cheeked switch hitting [censored] with a chud. Thats all he is. He was an arrogant [censored] redneck which is the opposite of Aaron or Maddux.
-
@JenkinMeyer_PSN said in Am I the only one?:
3 Braves and Bobby grich. Tell me you’re excited. No one is. They see chipper and move on.
And also, Chipper is one of the worst defensive players of all time. Hit it to chipper used to be our chant. Also allegedly hit his wife. He’s a switch hitter that’s all that matters. He’s a [censored] person and a [censored] card.
Our other chant was Larry Wayne.
Red cheeked switch hitting [censored] with a chud. Thats all he is. He was an arrogant [censored] redneck which is the opposite of Aaron or Maddux.
So what you're saying is he's a man of integrity, honesty, and genuine southern charm?
(In all seriousness, the abuse thing is purely speculation and I can't seem to find anything with my research on the matter. He has, however, said and done some pretty stupid [censored] when it comes to other people... particularly parroting dangerous and awful conspiracy theories.)
-
Sets and seasons was better
-
2019 and 2021 had the best models, pick one of those and dont stray too far from that path. I personally think 2019 had the best content model. Year long XP path with red diamonds was awesome.
-
Events had all this at one point. I remember when they actually used events to be creative. Different counts for each hitter. Remember those events. They are dropping the ball big time with creativity. They can do much more with ranked and events.
-
@nasty6669_PSN said in Am I the only one?:
Who actually kind of preferred the season format for players from last few years? Power creep makes DD just like every other sports game team building mode (ultimate team my team etc). I'm seeing very little variety in lineups, as live series and other cool cards quickly become "obsolete". Plus we are already at 97s?
I would love to see ranked revert back , but add more wild cards that have rating requirements. Like instead 1 or 2 wildcards you have to grind for , you get three right off the bat but have to below 90. Then you get another 1 or 2 that are <93 etc.
Or better yet have a separate ranked mode with HARD lineup requirements, not the overall limit that is easily manipulated: 2 players <99, 4 players <95 , 6 players <90, etc etc
Something please.
I do not agree on:
- Lineup diversity: In a power creep everybody has to decide what weaknesses he adresses. In 23/24 there were no weaknesses since everybody had mostly an all-99-god-squad-like squad with literally no holes starting in April. It is way better this year than 23/24 were at any given time.
- Live Series: They did not matter at all in 23/24 … Rn I am still playing Ketel at SS, Shohei and sometimes JRam … besides Clemens, Beltran and Hodges who never left my squad once I got them
- People use the same lineups: I do not agree on this too. Sure, some guys always come up (Buxton, Donaldson, Santana, Clemens) … but I usually see a big variety in my games I play. That was also not the case (mainly) in the last 2 years since everbody always played the collection guys (that were too easy to get)
I heavily agree:
- Lineup requirement modes: This I totally agree on … there should be a mode that is based on team building … e.g. like they do on tournaments (1 gold, 2 cards below x etc.) … that varies very often. Make use of the binder and adress those people who have a big binder.
-
@jaychvz_XBL said in Am I the only one?:
Sets and seasons was better
Imagine … 2 years of crying about sets&seasons everywhere and then this happens
(I meant „in general“ -
In a power creep the vast majority of people are just using the latest cards. Everyone has the same "weaknesses" because it's whatever strengths and weaknesses of the latest batch are.
It honestly wasnt any different with the last format either, because it was essentially a mini creep. But the difference was when the sets or seasons or whatever they called it would roll over. I found those first couple weeks of each cycle more fun and something to look forward to. That's where you really saw strengths and weaknesses. More rating restricted wildcards would have been even better.
