Your P5 list as of mid-May

[Pennstatefencer_MLBTS]

None for me. Not as much time to play combined with constant pxp missions from programs and team affinity. No one stays in my lineup long enough. I think I have a card close to p3

[dap1234567890_PSN]

I got 99 WBC Ohtani within my first three packs on day 1 and I had him P5'd by the end of day 2. I have not P5 any other cards, but have several at P4. With so many high level diamonds, I have been sharing playing time with a lot of them!

[BxnnyMxn__PSN]

So what happens once you’ve got someone there do they become noticeably better

I’d use a question mark but for some reason I can’t get to those characters

I really would like to hear

[urbanphilosophy_XBL]

I fractured TA1 Mullins and Acuna Jr. Number 60 for Mullins and 130 something with Acuna. Could’ve been too 30 and 100 but I had life stuff that kept me off Xbox for a week

[mjfc_363_PSN]

Nobody. Captains Andres Gimenez, Jeter and Happ at P4.

[GoTitans3_XBL]

@BxnnyMxn__PSN said in Your P5 list as of mid-May:

So what happens once you’ve got someone there do they become noticeably better

I’d use a question mark but for some reason I can’t get to those characters

I really would like to hear

Nah not really but it gets a pretty sparkly light blue border.

[Pergo_MLBTS]

None for me, but getting somewhat close with Rickey and Acuna both at P4 and about halfway to P5 I think.

[tybud_PSN]

I have 0, I am getting all my diamond and gold players to p1, it forces me to use everyone and it keeps the game fresh for me.

[RevCuddyer_PSN]

Buxton
Mauer
Michael A. Taylor
Correa
Polanco
Julien
Torii Hunter
Nathan
Thielbar
Taylor Rogers
Jovani Moran
Duran
Jax

... I'm noticing a theme!

[lckdb_XBL]

Chipper, Jeter, Jazz, Sosa, Dustin May

[iBonafideScrub__PSN]

Trout, Jazz, Chipper, Trea.

[Ryan92780_PSN]

Captain Judge and Charisma Stanton.

[CDNmoneymaker93_MLBTS]

No P5 I switch players in and out like batteries in my Xbox controller

[Bearsfan217_XBL]

Fergie Jenkins

[theBlindRhino_PSN]

Jeter
Jazz
Sosa
Gibson

[romeischillin_PSN]

P5'd my All-Star Al Leiter last night... I like it but won't be using it again until I need to use All-Star cards most likely since with me P5ing him it unlocked Captain Leiter.

[MycoSynth-Valde _MLBTS]

The closest I am is with Catfish Hunter at P3

[capardo_XBL]

None. Captain Bryce Harper and Trevor Hoffman are both at P3.

Offline only and rookie/vet (at most). Takes a long time to P5 someone with that combo.

[MetalNuck_XBL]

Zero. Got some P2’s but I’m not playing a ton and when I am I rotate players quite often.

[Finn_Scotus_MLBTS]

None yet but one I'm chasing to be the first to do it with. I'm close! Hoping the other 5 P4 ppl gave up when a newer card for him came out!