While it definitely stinks to continually see the same pitcher there is way bigger issues with co op.
Freezes are constant.
Sometimes you don't get the same pitcher or bench as your teammate.
Large cooldown time for having to quit out of freezeoffs.
Crossplay is almost unplayable.
Wins in freezeoffs actually making 1 player lose points and the other one gain points.
I'd like to see some of that fixed first because co op is fun when it functions properly on the rare occasion.