@Studman7 said in I'm quitting after 10+ years:

MLB the Show 15 and 16 were amazing (despite some flaws). 17 and 18 had too much RNG, but awesome content. In 19 and 20, the game play is just terrible. A pile of steaming [censored] with a zillion shiny cards that don't matter. This was my favorite game ever. I hate it now.

Alright, see ya next week

@Rambo_11k said in The people defending this game have been silenced:

The amount of posts all reporting the same BS happening has overwhelmed the defenders and they are out of excuses.

We now even have real MLB players disgusted by the gameplay, great idea by the way SDS.

I think we deserve an apology, after all, we were right and your excuses proved to be nothing but fake news.

Why do you care so much about other people’s opinions? You’ve got way too much invested in everybody else’s opinion and it’s sad, get a hobby. (Upvote before he reports me and I get banned again)

So, I’ll use my own situation as a for instance.

I am 2 teams away from completing collections. I need Nolan, story, bellinger, and buehler.

If I quick sold all the diamonds I had, it would come out to 140k, enough for 2 of the 4

If i quick sold every single gold from every team, you come out to 91k. Add them up and you have 251k and enough to buy bellinger, buehler, story, and Arenado..

I’m making this because I have no idea why I’m forced to hold on to useless gold cards.

I’d probably Be able to triple the amount of gold players by exchanging silvers.

I get the reasoning, but it feels so pay to win. Especially when they know the golds won’t be useful in a few weeks.

I think of the live series diamonds, I’d probably only keep a couple of them. Bellinger, trout, and acuna, and some of the pitching. They know that people are gonna stop using ls cards soon enough, especially with collection rewards. It’s just dumb they did this. I don’t care if it’s to be more like real card collecting, it’s pointless.

Guy was mad that I bought my team? Lol why do people care so much about how other people choose to live there life. It’s sad

1. Hitting needs to be tuned back to what it was March 13th. A vast majority of the player base does not care if people are getting slaughtered every time they turn the game on. I’d rather get smashed and know I can hit my way back in then think I’m gonna square a ball up for the game to tell me it’s “okay” contact.

2. Pitching control. Change ups hang, curve balls loop, sliders back up, and fastballs miss far too often. Again, just tune the engine a little bit.

3. Weird fielding quirkiness: first, the thing where you catch a ball of the wall kind of close to the wall and your guy takes a step, touches the walls the throws a lollipop to that rolls to the intended base. Second, I’ve only noticed this with Lindor, but since last year his fielding animations have been slow to the point of allowing base hits. It’s only him, but he takes forever to throw. The outfielders not trying to field balls off the wall when they’re lined up with it; there should be a circle like in a fly ball at the end of the trail to know where to stand to field it. Outfielders just move weird in general this year but at least we can dive.

Feel free to add anything else you think should be on the list. I may have missed some stuff.

Look, I get it, you got a monitor, a scuff, every kontrol freak, and the game isn’t rewarding you, but people have lost their jobs and are stuck at home, make the forum a nice place to come socialize with people who play the game. Nothing about any game is gonna Be perfect. In call of duty you’ll get shot in the back and in the show you might not get rewarded when you think you should, but we have bigger issues at hand and being toxic about pci feedback isn’t something anyone wants to see. Stop beating the dead horse and be happy. Everybody love everybody

@Dani_Joonge said in How many FOF have you done:

I have done 13 so far and i'm done now because the other ones are not that great. I'm interested how many you guys have completed.

24....I need quarantine to end

@LiLsmokey_1312 said in punishing players who refuse to throw strikes?:

Does anyone else think they should punish players who just consistently throw balls in the dirt or way above the zone the second they get in a bad situation bc I’m tired of getting runners on and not seeing a single pitch in the strike zone again in the at bat

I love to be punished, I’m a bad boy

People complained that we got too many 99s early in the game, so now they’re giving us dumbed down versions of those cards.

@MLBarf said in This isn’t baseball:

Just faced Alex Reyes for 7 innings, Kluber for the 8th and closes with Newhouser. Not sure why SDS is so concerned about tweaking the hitting timing window to be make hitting averages more life like when they permit this type of shenanigans.

Add to it these unrealistic diamond future star and prospect cards - how do they even come up with attributes for these guys? Is somebody really going to start Nolan Jones over Mike Schmidt in real life?

This isn’t baseball this is a sad sad joke.

Mike Schmidt is 70, so yeah, I’m taking Nolan Jones over Mike Schmidt

@ImDFC said in May player of the month cards:

@THE_Tomdawg69er said in May player of the month cards:

@samguenther1987 said in May player of the month cards:

Lightning cards have been for May

Bell (2019)
Verlander in (2018)
Corea In (2017)

It’s probably gonna be verlander since bell and Correa already have high 90s cards. Throw in potm Dietrich too

Correa and Bell do not have high 90s cards. They have high 80s

My bad, but still specialty diamonds

@samguenther1987 said in May player of the month cards:

Lightning cards have been for May

Bell (2019)
Verlander in (2018)
Corea In (2017)

It’s probably gonna be verlander since bell and Correa already have high 90s cards. Throw in potm Dietrich too

@MFundercover said in I'm done with this game:

Me: Perfect-Perfect = out, Good-Good = Out, Okay-Good =Out, Just late-Good= Out, Good-Good= Hit

Him: Late-Okay=Hit, Okay-Okay= HR, Okay-Good=Hit, Perfect-Perfect= Hit, Okay-Okay= Out

Playing BR, I noted these hits. You can't tell me the game is skill based when its completely randomized by the script.

Okay-okay doesn’t exist

@dodgerslakers1 said in Stage 3 affinities:

@Nanthrax_1 said in Stage 3 affinities:

They're going to be high school players, watch

Big Al 2019 LLWS 99 overall 125 power against lefties and righties

Man, are you big al or his dad or something? Cause otherwise the big al obsession is starting to get a bit serious...

@TooGood3434 said in Stage 3 affinities:

Way to go! You are awesome!

Woah, who told you that you could show positivity towards another player? This is the show nation, toxic comments only

@iluvhaunts said in Battle royale:

Screen froze while I’m undefeated and loving my BR team. Anything I can do or do I gotta close app? Been froze for 10-15 minutes.

When you say undefeated, how undefeated are you? Cause 1-0 ain’t worth the wAit but if you’re like, 5-0, then just wait till someone gives

The joke is making the same post twice thinking you’re entitled to something.

Sds makes these patches, puts out this survey, but if they actually wanted progress, they’d listen to people and give them day 1 hitting like they wanted. The ball flew off the bat day 1. Now it’s Mlb 18s pitching with Mlb 19s hitting. They should probably take a good hard look at the surveys, because the reviews from those will be scathing. Nobody is happy with this game, and it shows. Most of the top 50 is on Twitter blasting the game everyday, tagging the guys who make these patches. It’s just mind boggling that they see the issues and don’t do a [censored] thing to correct the issues

@dodgerslakers1 said in Quitting mlb the show. It’s a scam:

@Nanthrax_1 said in Quitting mlb the show. It’s a scam:

@Sunamo1 said in Quitting mlb the show. It’s a scam:

I spent 290,000 stubs on packs and DID NOT pull a single diamond player. Is this a sick joke? I’m quitting the game after that! 200 packs! I’m quitting. That’s not right

So you spent $200 real money, and spent it all on packs?? What were you hoping to pull? Mike Trout? You pretty much could have just bought him..

I bet you scored some sick golds! Enjoy Eduardo Escobar 3 times

$200 on a virtual card lmao
Whyyy ??

He didn’t even buy the card, he spun the roulette wheel

@dodgerslakers1 said in LLWS cards:

Make it happen SDS.
99 BIG AL. 125 on both sides.

The llws is a pretty mediocre representation of baseball, so it would fit in with this game