FWIW, pure analog from years past is not the same as timing this year. The major difference is that with pure analog you also had to direct the bat with the right stick. Meaning, if the pitch was on the inside and you wanted to pull it, you would have to push the right stick up and left (for a RH hitter). So timing was not the only component of it.
I can't tell you how many times I would have good timing on a outside pitch but roll over to SS because I didn't push the right stick towards RF. Because of the 'aim' mechanic, it caused the swing timing to be much more dynamic than it is in this years game. At least it feels that way. Now it doesn't matter which way you push the right stick as long as the timing is good. Really wish they would bring back pure analog; it was a very rewarding way to hit especially on higher difficulties.