Hey everyone so I had this same problem. In my case it had to do with my external storage being it full it wasn’t able to load saved data so I moved some things around cleaned up my internal storage on my Xbox and transferred mlb the show over to the Xbox one storage and restarted Xbox and everything worked I had 10 seasons of rtts and wasn’t about to lose all that hopefully this helps
J
JFLEM69_XBL
@JFLEM69_XBL