So just for fun...

[MrDeweyCoXX_PSN]

Jimmy Wynn , Jose Cruz , Lance Berkman

[jake98833_PSN]

Don Newcombe, Thurman Munson, Shoeless Joe Jackson

[PAinPA_PSN]

Lefty, Dutch,and Wild thing.

[douevenbench_MLBTS]

John Rocker
Bo
Pete Rose

[Teak2112_MLBTS]

Turk Wendell
Turk Wendell
Turk Wendell

But seriously

Edgardo Alfonzo
John Olerud
and yes, Turk Wendell

[The_Joneser_PSN]

Carney Lansford
Tim Hudson (as an Athletic, with his stinger)
Al Hrobosky

[xsdert34_PSN]

Hoyt Wilhelm, Tommy John, and Thurman Munson.

[imbeater_MLBTS]

Jose Reyes, Bartolo Colon, and Barry Bonds

[OlSkoolE63_MLBTS]

Bo Jackson
Dharyl Strawberry
Elston Howard

[DaKid24167_XBL]

Willie McGee
Rick Ankiel ( sick 2 way player card would be awesome)
Scott Rolen