I mean, I brought in Tyler Rogers and the tired sign came up after 1 batter. It seems to happen no matter who I bring in. Really making this game unenjoyable. Basically throwing BP. I have tried different pitching methods, several different ways to do analog and the result is always the same. Feels like my controller is having a spasm. Tried a different controller with the same result.
I guess if someone needs a HR derby pitcher, hit me up.