Three Topics Rolled Into One: Player Edition

[GooseOnEm_PSN]

Alright guys three opinions that I have so far after the first month.

1. The Mays card from last year is waaaay better than Mantle.

2. FoF Buxton is an absolute glitch.

3. MVP Larkin straight up takes.

That is all.

[Nanthrax_1_PSN]

If Mays plays a bit better than Mantle (I don't think he does thanks to Mickey's switch hitting and he's upgradeable), that because he was in real life.. so that's accurate..
Mays is top 3 all time. Mantle on the bubble of top 10

[GooseOnEm_PSN]

@Nanthrax_1 said in Three Topics Rolled Into One: Player Edition:

If Mays plays a bit better than Mantle (I don't think he does thanks to Mickey's switch hitting and he's upgradeable), that because he was in real life.. so that's accurate..
Mays is top 3 all time. Mantle on the bubble of top 10

I can agree with that. Mays last year was an elite defender and definitely had more pop.

[Nanthrax_1_PSN]

@GooseOnEm said in Three Topics Rolled Into One: Player Edition:

@Nanthrax_1 said in Three Topics Rolled Into One: Player Edition:

If Mays plays a bit better than Mantle (I don't think he does thanks to Mickey's switch hitting and he's upgradeable), that because he was in real life.. so that's accurate..
Mays is top 3 all time. Mantle on the bubble of top 10

I can agree with that. Mays last year was an elite defender and definitely had more pop.

Then they nailed the IRL counterparts, because Mays was a better defender, and had more pop.. well actually, funny enough they both had the exact same lifetime slugging %.. pretty amazing.. Mays played 4 more years thanks to better knees than Mick, and less of a drinking problem... If Mick didn't party so much, he would have had better health and therefore better legs, and would have been in the top 5 easily..
Just hanging out with Billy Martin too much probably cut Mick's career down 2 years.. at least