Collection Mantle
-
To those that have him; how are you hitting with him?
And did it take awhile to get in the groove with him?
It's a small sample size, as I had him in my last BR run (7 ABs) and I was under most of his swings.
I'd have to double check; buy I think I flied/popped out every AB.
-
@BIG_PAPIx34_PSN said in Collection Mantle:
I'd have to double check; buy I think I flied/popped out every AB.
That sounds to be more like a PCI placement error, a.k.a. user error, rather than an issue with the "greatest card of MLB the Show history" that has 125 ratings in CON R, CON L, PWR R, PWR L, DISC, CLT, and 102 in VIS.
I'd say to maybe adjust your PCI placement to fix the "flied/popped out every AB" issue!
-
This is the best version of Mantle yet imo. Hitting over .400 with him in the current event. Likely you're pressing so just stick with it!
-
@BIG_PAPIx34_PSN said in Collection Mantle:
To those that have him; how are you hitting with him?
And did it take awhile to get in the groove with him?
It's a small sample size, as I had him in my last BR run (7 ABs) and I was under most of his swings.
I'd have to double check; buy I think I flied/popped out every AB.
I have hit with him from the beginning and he has hit well for me on HOF also. Have not been disappointed.
-
I don’t have his card yet this year; but, to be fair since his card was first in the game in The Show 20 as the LS collection, some people have struggled with his swing. I do well with him, but I don’t hit well with cards other people do. Attributes are not everything. Last year I heard the same complaints about Mantle’s swing. So it isn’t necessarily an issue with PCI placement, it could be the timing. I don’t know if they changed his swing, but people feel pressured to keep a card in their lineup because it was a collection reward. Definitely give it more time. If you get his swing down you will be happy you did.
-
I’ve done poorly with him so far, but I do every year. Hitting .250 with 1 HR in 24 AB. I won’t give up on him until around 100 AB, but there’s a good chance of Reynolds taking his spot.
-
Started slow for me, but up to a .612 slugging, which is great for me.
-
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Collection Mantle:
I’ve done poorly with him so far, but I do every year. Hitting .250 with 1 HR in 24 AB. I won’t give up on him until around 100 AB, but there’s a good chance of Reynolds taking his spot.
Same here. I struggle with Mantle usually. But rip with much less. Most switch hitters I seem to struggle with it seems.
-
A admin locked this topic on
