I played a CPU game on my Switch today and noticed the Progress screen was blank. My squad was a Legends of the Franchise players vs the Royals (in Minute Maid Park).
When I looked at the game history, I had 4 homers, 16 Ks, and 9 innings pitched (I didn't figure out how many TB I had).
Then I looked at my notes where I was in the Last Call mission and saw that it compiled my stats. The only thing wrong was that the Progress screen didn't show my progress.
BTW, I purchased a Switch Pro controller and it makes a ton of difference playing the game on the Switch. I think I'm going to get some Kontrol Freeks for it to see how they feel. I like them on my PS5 controller.