Question for those who use analog/stride

So those challenges where you're asked to do a "contact" swing or "power swing" are always a failure for me. I'm a second baseman and made myself a contact hitter. So I select on "contact" swing for those challenges but I get failure even when I do get a hit.

Does it always think analog stride is always a power swing?

Do we know how to do a power vs contact in analog stride like the way you do with the buttons?

It doesn't make sense to me.

Thanks

You have to select contact or power swing before the pitch is thrown.

Use whichever you think will be successful against that particular pitcher.

How does the system know a power swing from a contact swing if I use the analog stick and stride. It's always the same motion.

Contact vs power is for buttons, right?