Defensive upgrade/downgrade

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

There is NO WAY that Altuve's defense doesn't go down, right? https://www.mlb.com/video/00u8w5i3qdDNsKVda356/reels/jose-altuve-postseason-errors Here is a reel I made of his errors in the postseason, that I could find.

And Mark Melancon's has to go up, right? https://www.mlb.com/video/the-albies-melancon-connection
This is not a reel, just two plays in one video.