TA 3 reveal thread
-
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Renz2003 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
Mark my words the Cle TA will NOT be thome or manny
I literally don’t think there are any other options though
Yup. 9th in Team WAR and fits with the motif for the year, plus recently HOF. Thome has to be it.
I also say that Angels will be Tim Salmon and Blue Jays is Roy Halladay
-
@teamJambon said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Renz2003 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
Mark my words the Cle TA will NOT be thome or manny
I literally don’t think there are any other options though
Well it could be Grady Sizemore.
Grady Sizemore wouldn’t be a 99. No chance
-
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@teamJambon said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Renz2003 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
Mark my words the Cle TA will NOT be thome or manny
I literally don’t think there are any other options though
Well it could be Grady Sizemore.
Grady Sizemore wouldn’t be a 99. No chance
You never know, none of these ratings make any sense.
-
Grady Sizemore could be a 99 IMO. From 2006-2008 he was one of the best all around players in the game. He averaged 25 homers, 80 RBIs and 30 SB, and won a couple gold gloves. Very good player until the injuries hampered him.
-
If they can give Michael Young, AJ Burnett, and Jason Kendall 97s, they can give anyone high diamonds. Jose Mesa, Carlos Baerga, Charles Nagy, anybody.
-
@formallyforearms said in TA 3 reveal thread:
If they can give Michael Young, AJ Burnett, and Jason Kendall 97s, they can give anyone high diamonds. Jose Mesa, Carlos Baerga, Charles Nagy, anybody.
I’m just saying look at the other 99’s in TA 3. George Brett, Harmon Killebrew, Gwynn, Schmidt, etc. -all time greats. Thome certainly fits that mold. Sizemore doesn’t. 97-98 sure. Don’t give me the the future star nonsense either. Those are unrealistic on purpose and can’t be compared here
-
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@formallyforearms said in TA 3 reveal thread:
If they can give Michael Young, AJ Burnett, and Jason Kendall 97s, they can give anyone high diamonds. Jose Mesa, Carlos Baerga, Charles Nagy, anybody.
I’m just saying look at the other 99’s in TA 3. George Brett, Harmon Killebrew, Gwynn, Schmidt, etc. -all time greats. Thome certainly fits that mold. Sizemore doesn’t. 97-98 sure. Don’t give me the the future star nonsense either. Those are unrealistic on purpose and can’t be compared here
Sizemore was raw but yeah not a 99, and I don't see it being Manny either. Gotta be Thome
-
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Renz2003 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
Mark my words the Cle TA will NOT be thome or manny
I literally don’t think there are any other options though
Nap Lajoie or Tris Speaker? Snoooooze
-
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Renz2003 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
Mark my words the Cle TA will NOT be thome or manny
I literally don’t think there are any other options though
Jose mesa
-
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Renz2003 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
Mark my words the Cle TA will NOT be thome or manny
I literally don’t think there are any other options though
Nap Lajoie or Tris Speaker? Snoooooze
They don’t really fit the era that all the rest of these are in though. Isn’t the oldest legend in TA3 like Killebrew? Lol
-
My Prediction:
Angels - Jim Edmonds or Nolan Ryan
Blue Jays - Robbie Alomar or Dave Stieb
Indians - Kenny Lofton or Albert Belle -
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
My Prediction:
Angels - Jim Edmonds or Nolan Ryan
Blue Jays - Robbie Alomar or Dave Stieb
Indians - Kenny Lofton or Albert BelleThey're new legends. Everyone you named has been in DD already
-
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Renz2003 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
Mark my words the Cle TA will NOT be thome or manny
I literally don’t think there are any other options though
Nap Lajoie or Tris Speaker? Snoooooze
They don’t really fit the era that all the rest of these are in though. Isn’t the oldest legend in TA3 like Killebrew? Lol
I agree. I'm just saying they're Indian legends and options. Both would be terrible options though
-
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
My Prediction:
Angels - Jim Edmonds or Nolan Ryan
Blue Jays - Robbie Alomar or Dave Stieb
Indians - Kenny Lofton or Albert BelleThey're new legends. Everyone you named has been in DD already
Dammit I keep forgetting that...lol. Good catch. I guess I have to go with the Thome train with the Indians then, and probably Salmon or Wally Joyner for the Angels. Maybe George Bell or Damaso Garcia for the Jays?
-
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
My Prediction:
Angels - Jim Edmonds or Nolan Ryan
Blue Jays - Robbie Alomar or Dave Stieb
Indians - Kenny Lofton or Albert BelleThey're new legends. Everyone you named has been in DD already
Dammit I keep forgetting that...lol. Good catch. I guess I have to go with the Thome train with the Indians then, and probably Salmon or Wally Joyner for the Angels. Maybe George Bell or Damaso Garcia for the Jays?
Damaso Garcia... That would make me want to throw a toaster in the tub
Hoping Delgado or Doc.. nobody else..
Tony Fernandez would make sense too, but pretty boring -
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
My Prediction:
Angels - Jim Edmonds or Nolan Ryan
Blue Jays - Robbie Alomar or Dave Stieb
Indians - Kenny Lofton or Albert BelleThey're new legends. Everyone you named has been in DD already
Dammit I keep forgetting that...lol. Good catch. I guess I have to go with the Thome train with the Indians then, and probably Salmon or Wally Joyner for the Angels. Maybe George Bell or Damaso Garcia for the Jays?
Damaso Garcia... That would make me want to throw a toaster in the tub
Hoping Delgado or Doc.. nobody else..
Tony Fernandez would make sense too, but pretty boringDidn't Tony have a card last year though?
-
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@formallyforearms said in TA 3 reveal thread:
If they can give Michael Young, AJ Burnett, and Jason Kendall 97s, they can give anyone high diamonds. Jose Mesa, Carlos Baerga, Charles Nagy, anybody.
I’m just saying look at the other 99’s in TA 3. George Brett, Harmon Killebrew, Gwynn, Schmidt, etc. -all time greats. Thome certainly fits that mold. Sizemore doesn’t. 97-98 sure. Don’t give me the the future star nonsense either. Those are unrealistic on purpose and can’t be compared here
I hate the future stars, so I'm not on that train, but I dont see how them giving Burnett a 97 isnt that much different than Travis Hafner or even Grady Sizemore a 99. They are all unworthy.
-
@formallyforearms said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@formallyforearms said in TA 3 reveal thread:
If they can give Michael Young, AJ Burnett, and Jason Kendall 97s, they can give anyone high diamonds. Jose Mesa, Carlos Baerga, Charles Nagy, anybody.
I’m just saying look at the other 99’s in TA 3. George Brett, Harmon Killebrew, Gwynn, Schmidt, etc. -all time greats. Thome certainly fits that mold. Sizemore doesn’t. 97-98 sure. Don’t give me the the future star nonsense either. Those are unrealistic on purpose and can’t be compared here
I hate the future stars, so I'm not on that train, but I dont see how them giving Burnett a 97 isnt that much different than Travis Hafner or even Grady Sizemore a 99. They are all unworthy.
@formallyforearms said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@the_dragon1912 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@formallyforearms said in TA 3 reveal thread:
If they can give Michael Young, AJ Burnett, and Jason Kendall 97s, they can give anyone high diamonds. Jose Mesa, Carlos Baerga, Charles Nagy, anybody.
I’m just saying look at the other 99’s in TA 3. George Brett, Harmon Killebrew, Gwynn, Schmidt, etc. -all time greats. Thome certainly fits that mold. Sizemore doesn’t. 97-98 sure. Don’t give me the the future star nonsense either. Those are unrealistic on purpose and can’t be compared here
I hate the future stars, so I'm not on that train, but I dont see how them giving Burnett a 97 isnt that much different than Travis Hafner or even Grady Sizemore a 99. They are all unworthy.
Thats completely a result of
- They didn’t want to rate any of the cards below 97
- Marlins not having any options
- SDS digging themselves a whole and releasing 87 Cliff Floyd in the 5th inning program. Because that was a more obvious choice than Bichette if not for the 87 just released
-
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
My Prediction:
Angels - Jim Edmonds or Nolan Ryan
Blue Jays - Robbie Alomar or Dave Stieb
Indians - Kenny Lofton or Albert BelleThey're new legends. Everyone you named has been in DD already
Dammit I keep forgetting that...lol. Good catch. I guess I have to go with the Thome train with the Indians then, and probably Salmon or Wally Joyner for the Angels. Maybe George Bell or Damaso Garcia for the Jays?
Damaso Garcia... That would make me want to throw a toaster in the tub
Hoping Delgado or Doc.. nobody else..
Tony Fernandez would make sense too, but pretty boringDidn't Tony have a card last year though?
No. Never has. He passed away this year, so maybe they honor him by getting him in the game. RIP
-
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@Nanthrax_1 said in TA 3 reveal thread:
@PeuswahBoy said in TA 3 reveal thread:
My Prediction:
Angels - Jim Edmonds or Nolan Ryan
Blue Jays - Robbie Alomar or Dave Stieb
Indians - Kenny Lofton or Albert BelleThey're new legends. Everyone you named has been in DD already
Dammit I keep forgetting that...lol. Good catch. I guess I have to go with the Thome train with the Indians then, and probably Salmon or Wally Joyner for the Angels. Maybe George Bell or Damaso Garcia for the Jays?
Damaso Garcia... That would make me want to throw a toaster in the tub
Hoping Delgado or Doc.. nobody else..
Tony Fernandez would make sense too, but pretty boringDidn't Tony have a card last year though?
No. Never has. He passed away this year, so maybe they honor him by getting him in the game. RIP
I wouldn't hate that. Tony was a historically underrated player, IMO.
