Chapman vs Dibble

SDS

@jonnydaman said in Chapman vs Dibble:

Both are great but I think the live series Chapman isn't that far off of the 97 Chapman so I would go with dibble

He is 150% different that the LS. The added change up is the difference. Can be thrown to righty’s or lefty’s effectively. Also the outlier sinker helps big time as well.

SDS

Dibble is head and shoulders above anyone. I don’t think SS Chapman is much better than LS Chapman, but both are good.

SDS

@KommanderNKeef9 said in Chapman vs Dibble:

@jonnydaman said in Chapman vs Dibble:

Both are great but I think the live series Chapman isn't that far off of the 97 Chapman so I would go with dibble

He is 150% different that the LS. The added change up is the difference. Can be thrown to righty’s or lefty’s effectively. Also the outlier sinker helps big time as well.

The changeup is nice but I think the fastball/silder combo is good enough to not really need the changeup and I prefer the mid 80s slider on the live series Chapman more than the 90 mph slider on the 97 Chapman so I think the difference is small.
The 97 might have outlier on the sinker but im not a fan of the sinker for either card so that's only a small deal in my opinion

SDS

@jonnydaman said in Chapman vs Dibble:

@KommanderNKeef9 said in Chapman vs Dibble:

@jonnydaman said in Chapman vs Dibble:

Both are great but I think the live series Chapman isn't that far off of the 97 Chapman so I would go with dibble

He is 150% different that the LS. The added change up is the difference. Can be thrown to righty’s or lefty’s effectively. Also the outlier sinker helps big time as well.

The changeup is nice but I think the fastball/silder combo is good enough to not really need the changeup and I prefer the mid 80s slider on the live series Chapman more than the 90 mph slider on the 97 Chapman so I think the difference is small.
The 97 might have outlier on the sinker but im not a fan of the sinker for either card so that's only a small deal in my opinion

And the 2 seam as well.

SDS

@jonnydaman said in Chapman vs Dibble:

@KommanderNKeef9 said in Chapman vs Dibble:

@jonnydaman said in Chapman vs Dibble:

Both are great but I think the live series Chapman isn't that far off of the 97 Chapman so I would go with dibble

He is 150% different that the LS. The added change up is the difference. Can be thrown to righty’s or lefty’s effectively. Also the outlier sinker helps big time as well.

The changeup is nice but I think the fastball/silder combo is good enough to not really need the changeup and I prefer the mid 80s slider on the live series Chapman more than the 90 mph slider on the 97 Chapman so I think the difference is small.
The 97 might have outlier on the sinker but im not a fan of the sinker for either card so that's only a small deal in my opinion

Fair points. One thing I’ve learned about this years game, is that to each his own! Cards play different for different folks!