"Topps Now" Amir Garrett vs. Chapman

SDS

IMO there's no reason to pay nearly 30k stubs for Chapman when you can easily acquire Garrett through the Moments.

I've had him on my DD squad since the card was released. This guy is nasty!!

Anyone have both? Thoughts?

SDS

I agree, I’ve had waaaaay more success with Garrett.

SDS

People get Chapman to spam his 99 Break Sinker, also his HR/9 is better. Garrett has a SLIGHTLY better Slider but his 2SFB has garbage ratings. He's good for free, but Chapman is still gonna play better vs most people.

SDS

@Catman9186 said in "Topps Now" Amir Garrett vs. Chapman:

IMO there's no reason to pay nearly 30k stubs for Chapman when you can easily acquire Garrett through the Moments.

I've had him on my DD squad since the card was released. This guy is nasty!!

Anyone have both? Thoughts?

Chapman and Amir are not comparable, Chapman is heads and shoulders above Amir. More pitches, a sinker and he has outlier.

Amir is comparable to Hader, who I feel Amir is slightly better than if you can locate the slider

SDS

Garrett is probably the easiest Diamond RP to hit against imo and im terrible online...

SDS

@DrIuigi said in "Topps Now" Amir Garrett vs. Chapman:

@Catman9186 said in "Topps Now" Amir Garrett vs. Chapman:

IMO there's no reason to pay nearly 30k stubs for Chapman when you can easily acquire Garrett through the Moments.

I've had him on my DD squad since the card was released. This guy is nasty!!

Anyone have both? Thoughts?

Chapman and Amir are not comparable, Chapman is heads and shoulders above Amir. More pitches, a sinker and he has outlier.

Amir is comparable to Hader, who I feel Amir is slightly better than if you can locate the slider

This 100%

SDS

More comparable to Hader than Chapman, Chapman having outlier and a sinker pretty much bolsters by Amir, still not a bad free card tho even tho I don’t use him I use Wagner an Chapman as my two lefty’s along as Hal out of the pen