That's it!

[go4stros25_PSN]

Bryan Reynolds is the best FOTF card!! Tommy Edman close second. 2 walk off hits in a row. The man stays in the lineup.

Also Webb might be the best pitcher. I don't have him, but I can't pick up pitches out of his hand to save my life.

[the_dragon1912_PSN]

I love both of those cards, but Haniger has been the best of them for me by a long shot

[Mothers Milk237_XBL]

Agree on Edman & Webb. But Reynolds?

[Random_Schmuck_PSN]

100% agree on Reynolds. I have him at PXP 5 and even as better OF come out he will always have a place on my squad.

Edman? I want to love Edman, but Durham and other great 2B options keep him as a late inning defensive replacement, bench bat and extra innings ghost runner. If only he were eligible at 1b I could utilize him more as a pinch runner when my slow af 1b gets a late innings single. As it is he is fighting Cronenworth for a spot on the bench.

[RobbyBobby88_MLBTS]

No way any fotf card is better than beli dude slapping above .550 in 15+ games w bombs coming off his bat frequently

[virusts_XBL]

@the_dragon1912 said in That's it!:

I love both of those cards, but Haniger has been the best of them for me by a long shot

Yeah Haniger and Devers for me has been amazing. I couldn't hit with Devers last year or when I first got him, but he's on a roll for me now.

[ChuckCLC_PSN]

Devers has been my best. Think he is the only one I still use.

[Ericulous1_PSN]

@the_dragon1912 said in That's it!:

I love both of those cards, but Haniger has been the best of them for me by a long shot

Dude, Haniger slays man. I bought him just for the Mariners mission points in the Cover player program and he's already got like 10 bombs in a few days and is hitting over .500. Iean, I play mostly on All Star against CPU so I'm not going to give myself a medal or anything but, what an underrated card.

OP, I waited until the end of last year to rry Reynolds' Finest and it turned out to be my favorite hitting card of that series. This card is fantastic too.

My top 5: (because I always have to have a top 5)

1. Rafael Devers
2. Mitch Haniger
3. Bryan Reynolds
4. Wander Franco
5. Emmanuel Clase

[RetroGZY_XBL]

The RPs have the most staying power

[dbarmonstar_PSN]

Offline hitters
1 Chisholm has some power and is clutch
2 Buxton
3 Edman
4 Bellinger
5 Kelly

Can not hit with Devers

Pitching
Champman
Clase
Williams

[dbub_PSN]

This thread is fraudulent since no one has even mentioned THE GOAT...

Cedric Mullins. I've completed Live Series and Cedric is still destroying pitchers from my leadoff spot.

Side note - Mullins is actually way better online than off.