@Mike__Honcho_361 said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

Ok everyone, so:
I know that this is dumb, as I keep changing the team, but I think this is what I am going to use for a bit. This will be the last request for lineups for a bit.
Trout
Mantle
Griffey
Freeman
Story
Tatis
Machado
Perez
(I like my team, and don't want to change it, just want to change my lineup)
Again, thanks for your help!

I’ll give you my lineup suggestion, but could you also include how you hit with them? Either an Avg or just rate them based on your experience with each? I think that makes a difference.

To be honest, I haven't played lately, so I don't know. I just bought or got, and haven't played with: Trout, Griffey, Freeman, Story (Did well with his LS early in the year), Machado, and Perez. So everyone is new but Tatis and Mantle. lol

Haha ok then one way to go would be:

Tatis
Trout
Mantle
Griffey
Machado
Freeman
Perez
Story

You can tweak it a bit. The cards are so good it’s not a huge difference to move them around. I personally like to have a RH hitter that mashes lefties between my LH hitters. Always good to have speed up
Top and when possible I like someone with decent speed in the 8 hole.

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

Ok everyone, so:
I know that this is dumb, as I keep changing the team, but I think this is what I am going to use for a bit. This will be the last request for lineups for a bit.
Trout
Mantle
Griffey
Freeman
Story
Tatis
Machado
Perez
(I like my team, and don't want to change it, just want to change my lineup)
Again, thanks for your help!

I’ll give you my lineup suggestion, but could you also include how you hit with them? Either an Avg or just rate them based on your experience with each? I think that makes a difference.

To be honest, I haven't played lately, so I don't know. I just bought or got, and haven't played with: Trout, Griffey, Freeman, Story (Did well with his LS early in the year), Machado, and Perez. So everyone is new but Tatis and Mantle. lol

Ok everyone, so:
I know that this is dumb, as I keep changing the team, but I think this is what I am going to use for a bit. This will be the last request for lineups for a bit.
Trout
Mantle
Griffey
Freeman
Story
Tatis
Machado
Perez
(I like my team, and don't want to change it, just want to change my lineup)
Again, thanks for your help!

I’ll give you my lineup suggestion, but could you also include how you hit with them? Either an Avg or just rate them based on your experience with each? I think that makes a difference.

Do you have Finest Betts? I’ve had my CAP at 2B most of the year but I recently started using Betts there since OF is overloaded and I’m loving his card. Def worth a shot. I also couldn’t get it going with Hornsby’s card so I kinda gave up on him early.

Also, Freddie’s swing is awesome and he has that diamond D at 1B. How do you like him so far?

I haven't used Freddie yet. I might get Betts. Thanks for the recommendation!

Also, Freddie’s swing is awesome and he has that diamond D at 1B. How do you like him so far?

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@Ikasnu with ZERO bias, which will be hard for you, how is he? Better than Hornsby?

I'd put Mondesi at 2B tbh.

If you don't have him?

@Ikasnu with ZERO bias, which will be hard for you, how is he? Better than Hornsby?

I'd put Mondesi at 2B tbh.

Such disappointment

I am thinking about buying 99 Story for 2B. Not sure yet.

1. Mantle
2. Tatis
3. Trout
4. Griffey
5. Hornsby
6. Thome
7. Machado
8. Pitcher
9. Biggio

Maybe flip tatis and trout. You could also swap Hornsby and Machado and be fine.

ogram and replace Hornsby with seager

I don't have time for that. I will start soon though.

I just bought Freeman for 1B. So, now I have:
Trout
Mantle
Griffey
Machado
Tatis
Hornsby
Freeman
99 Perez
Does the lineup change?
Also, thoughts on Bryce Harper and Frank Thomas as bench bats? Are they any good?
Thanks!

Do thy World Series program and replace Hornsby with seager

@raesONE said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE
So, I got Perez. Who do I take off of my bench?
My bench:
Killebrew
Cano
Alonso
Sheffield
Winker
I would put Biggio on the bench.

Killebrew

Instead of Alonso? Second, how does my lineup look with Perez? The same? There isn't any speed behing Machado anymore.

@WarriorsAreCool7 said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

So, what do I do with my lineup now that I have Perez as my C? Does that change anything?

Have you done World Series Program I might try D’ whatever at catcher and Seager or Correa at second

No, I haven't. I just bought Perez, but was thinking about d'Arnaud.

Yeah I prefer Alonso, but it's a personal preference thing I guess.

I would keep everything the same but switch Tatic to #8 and plug Perez in the #5 spot.

I also have Reggie, 99 Correa, 99 Acuna, 99 Dawson, 99 Yount, 99 Gqynn, and 99 Sandberg that I can use on ,y bench. Choices, choices, choices.....

Nah they're not worth it

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE
So, I got Perez. Who do I take off of my bench?
My bench:
Killebrew
Cano
Alonso
Sheffield
Winker
I would put Biggio on the bench.

Killebrew

Instead of Alonso? Second, how does my lineup look with Perez? The same? There isn't any speed behing Machado anymore.

@WarriorsAreCool7 said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

So, what do I do with my lineup now that I have Perez as my C? Does that change anything?

Have you done World Series Program I might try D’ whatever at catcher and Seager or Correa at second

No, I haven't. I just bought Perez, but was thinking about d'Arnaud.

Yeah I prefer Alonso, but it's a personal preference thing I guess.

I would keep everything the same but switch Tatic to #8 and plug Perez in the #5 spot.

I also have Reggie, 99 Correa, 99 Acuna, 99 Dawson, 99 Yount, 99 Gqynn, and 99 Sandberg that I can use on ,y bench. Choices, choices, choices.....

Maybe Correa over Hornsby

I had heard good things about both. Do you think that is the move?

@raesONE said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE
So, I got Perez. Who do I take off of my bench?
My bench:
Killebrew
Cano
Alonso
Sheffield
Winker
I would put Biggio on the bench.

Killebrew

Instead of Alonso? Second, how does my lineup look with Perez? The same? There isn't any speed behing Machado anymore.

@WarriorsAreCool7 said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

So, what do I do with my lineup now that I have Perez as my C? Does that change anything?

Have you done World Series Program I might try D’ whatever at catcher and Seager or Correa at second

No, I haven't. I just bought Perez, but was thinking about d'Arnaud.

Yeah I prefer Alonso, but it's a personal preference thing I guess.

I would keep everything the same but switch Tatic to #8 and plug Perez in the #5 spot.

I also have Reggie, 99 Correa, 99 Acuna, 99 Dawson, 99 Yount, 99 Gqynn, and 99 Sandberg that I can use on ,y bench. Choices, choices, choices.....

Maybe Correa over Hornsby

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE
So, I got Perez. Who do I take off of my bench?
My bench:
Killebrew
Cano
Alonso
Sheffield
Winker
I would put Biggio on the bench.

Killebrew

Instead of Alonso? Second, how does my lineup look with Perez? The same? There isn't any speed behing Machado anymore.

@WarriorsAreCool7 said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

So, what do I do with my lineup now that I have Perez as my C? Does that change anything?

Have you done World Series Program I might try D’ whatever at catcher and Seager or Correa at second

No, I haven't. I just bought Perez, but was thinking about d'Arnaud.

Yeah I prefer Alonso, but it's a personal preference thing I guess.

I would keep everything the same but switch Tatic to #8 and plug Perez in the #5 spot.

I also have Reggie, 99 Correa, 99 Acuna, 99 Dawson, 99 Yount, 99 Gqynn, and 99 Sandberg that I can use on ,y bench. Choices, choices, choices.....

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE
So, I got Perez. Who do I take off of my bench?
My bench:
Killebrew
Cano
Alonso
Sheffield
Winker
I would put Biggio on the bench.

Killebrew

Instead of Alonso? Second, how does my lineup look with Perez? The same? There isn't any speed behing Machado anymore.

@WarriorsAreCool7 said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

So, what do I do with my lineup now that I have Perez as my C? Does that change anything?

Have you done World Series Program I might try D’ whatever at catcher and Seager or Correa at second

No, I haven't. I just bought Perez, but was thinking about d'Arnaud.

Yeah I prefer Alonso, but it's a personal preference thing I guess.

I would keep everything the same but switch Tatic to #8 and plug Perez in the #5 spot.

Sweet, thanks!

@raesONE said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE
So, I got Perez. Who do I take off of my bench?
My bench:
Killebrew
Cano
Alonso
Sheffield
Winker
I would put Biggio on the bench.

Killebrew

Instead of Alonso? Second, how does my lineup look with Perez? The same? There isn't any speed behing Machado anymore.

@WarriorsAreCool7 said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

So, what do I do with my lineup now that I have Perez as my C? Does that change anything?

Have you done World Series Program I might try D’ whatever at catcher and Seager or Correa at second

No, I haven't. I just bought Perez, but was thinking about d'Arnaud.

Yeah I prefer Alonso, but it's a personal preference thing I guess.

I would keep everything the same but switch Tatis to #8 and plug Perez in the #5 spot.

@raesONE said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

@raesONE
So, I got Perez. Who do I take off of my bench?
My bench:
Killebrew
Cano
Alonso
Sheffield
Winker
I would put Biggio on the bench.

Killebrew

Instead of Alonso? Second, how does my lineup look with Perez? The same? There isn't any speed behing Machado anymore.

@WarriorsAreCool7 said in Set my lineup!:

@jz2016cubs said in Set my lineup!:

So, what do I do with my lineup now that I have Perez as my C? Does that change anything?

Have you done World Series Program I might try D’ whatever at catcher and Seager or Correa at second

No, I haven't. I just bought Perez, but was thinking about d'Arnaud.

It is definitely worth the time to do it