@eatyum said in Castellanos:

I mean Castellanos is decent, but he isn't better. Especially in terms of defense, is Cobb worth whatever stubs he is more then Castellanos? Probably not, but Cobb is better.

What about putting Nick at 3rd, and benching Gary? Thoughts?

I did that, he plays solid defense there. He is a good bat. I started really hot with him and cooled off but that’s because I’m a bad hitter

@TEXAS10PT said in Castellanos:

Only outfield that isn’t Cobb Trout and Mantle can only be improved when Mays comes out and then there will be a big dilemma LOL

What is your guess on how they will release Mays? If the 10th inning is finest, and the 11th is like last year. Does this mean he will be a WS or BR reward?

I’m pretty upset he is not out yet being a Giants fan. If he is a BR or WS reward I think that will be pretty cheap since he was the collection reward last year. In any case I’m sitting on a little over 2M waiting for him to be released.

@buttmuncher150 said in Castellanos:

@TEXAS10PT said in Castellanos:

Only outfield that isn’t Cobb Trout and Mantle can only be improved when Mays comes out and then there will be a big dilemma LOL

What is your guess on how they will release Mays? If the 10th inning is finest, and the 11th is like last year. Does this mean he will be a WS or BR reward?

Not BR, or the MLBTheShow community will go NUTS, and probably riot. Same with Griffey, if not more so.
I am starting to think that 10th inning won't be finest. What was the 11th last year? I forgot.

I’m thinking it won’t be* either because those are two great players that have to be released. But Griffey was a Boss last year so idk what they will do with him
Last year the 11th inning was or was over 1500 stars and it had a bunch of boss packs and other things that were released throughout the year

@TEXAS10PT said in Castellanos:

Only outfield that isn’t Cobb Trout and Mantle can only be improved when Mays comes out and then there will be a big dilemma LOL

What is your guess on how they will release Mays? If the 10th inning is finest, and the 11th is like last year. Does this mean he will be a WS or BR reward?

Not BR, or the MLBTheShow community will go NUTS, and probably riot. Same with Griffey, if not more so.
I am starting to think that 10th inning won't be finest. What was the 11th last year? I forgot.

Only outfield that isn’t Cobb Trout and Mantle can only be improved when Mays comes out and then there will be a big dilemma LOL

What is your guess on how they will release Mays? If the 10th inning is finest, and the 11th is like last year. Does this mean he will be a WS or BR reward?

Only outfield that isn’t Cobb Trout and Mantle can only be improved when Mays comes out and then there will be a big dilemma LOL

Sweet, that getting Trout will put me in a good spot.

@jz2016cubs said in Castellanos:

@lazy_toast said in Castellanos:

@jz2016cubs said in Castellanos:

@eatyum said in Castellanos:

I mean Castellanos is decent, but he isn't better. Especially in terms of defense, is Cobb worth whatever stubs he is more then Castellanos? Probably not, but Cobb is better.

What about putting Nick at 3rd, and benching Gary? Thoughts?

I benched Gary for Castellanos, then benched Castellanos for JRAM.

And you benched JRAM for...……

Blasphemy. JRAM does not get benched.

Honestly though i had a hard time moving past Sandoval at 3rd but Ramirez just hits tanks for days so i can't take him out of my main lineup.

I know.
He had said "I benched A for B. I then benched b for c." So I was saying. And you benched c for d?

@lazy_toast said in Castellanos:

@jz2016cubs said in Castellanos:

@eatyum said in Castellanos:

I mean Castellanos is decent, but he isn't better. Especially in terms of defense, is Cobb worth whatever stubs he is more then Castellanos? Probably not, but Cobb is better.

What about putting Nick at 3rd, and benching Gary? Thoughts?

I benched Gary for Castellanos, then benched Castellanos for JRAM.

And you benched JRAM for...……

Blasphemy. JRAM does not get benched.

Honestly though i had a hard time moving past Sandoval at 3rd but Ramirez just hits tanks for days so i can't take him out of my main lineup.

I like Castellanos and he has a great bat (Excellent for the bench) but Cobb is one of the best cards this year. I've just stuck him in the leadoff spot and kept him there he does the rest and he is beyond clutch. It seems any time I need a big hit he comes though and it's not just singles he has sneaky power. Plus Cobb can field.

Thanks! I sold Cobb to help me get Trout, but will be buying him back.

@lazy_toast said in Castellanos:

@jz2016cubs said in Castellanos:

@eatyum said in Castellanos:

I mean Castellanos is decent, but he isn't better. Especially in terms of defense, is Cobb worth whatever stubs he is more then Castellanos? Probably not, but Cobb is better.

What about putting Nick at 3rd, and benching Gary? Thoughts?

I benched Gary for Castellanos, then benched Castellanos for JRAM.

And you benched JRAM for...……

People complain about his small strike zone but it doesnt bother me one bit. Less chasing out of the zone because its a smaller window

@lazy_toast said in Castellanos:

@jz2016cubs said in Castellanos:

@eatyum said in Castellanos:

I mean Castellanos is decent, but he isn't better. Especially in terms of defense, is Cobb worth whatever stubs he is more then Castellanos? Probably not, but Cobb is better.

What about putting Nick at 3rd, and benching Gary? Thoughts?

I benched Gary for Castellanos, then benched Castellanos for JRAM.

And you benched JRAM for...……

LOL no one. He is still my starting 3B hitting above .300 with amazing power. I would put Castellanos in the outfield but would make me very righty heavy so hes on the bench but first one up

@jz2016cubs said in Castellanos:

@eatyum said in Castellanos:

I mean Castellanos is decent, but he isn't better. Especially in terms of defense, is Cobb worth whatever stubs he is more then Castellanos? Probably not, but Cobb is better.

What about putting Nick at 3rd, and benching Gary? Thoughts?

I benched Gary for Castellanos, then benched Castellanos for JRAM.

And you benched JRAM for...……

@eatyum said in Castellanos:

I mean Castellanos is decent, but he isn't better. Especially in terms of defense, is Cobb worth whatever stubs he is more then Castellanos? Probably not, but Cobb is better.

What about putting Nick at 3rd, and benching Gary? Thoughts?

I benched Gary for Castellanos, then benched Castellanos for JRAM.

@eatyum said in Castellanos:

I mean Castellanos is decent, but he isn't better. Especially in terms of defense, is Cobb worth whatever stubs he is more then Castellanos? Probably not, but Cobb is better.

What about putting Nick at 3rd, and benching Gary? Thoughts?

I played better with Gary, so for me it's Gary at third, but I don't know how you play with the two cards

I mean Castellanos is decent, but he isn't better. Especially in terms of defense, is Cobb worth whatever stubs he is more then Castellanos? Probably not, but Cobb is better.

What about putting Nick at 3rd, and benching Gary? Thoughts?