Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?

I’ll have Prestige Sheff soon and I’ve been using him at 3B with no real problems defensively so far. Been using TA Brett at 1B until I get Musial. Once I get Musial, who do I move to 3B? My OF is LF Mantle, CF Super Trout, RF Walker so there is no room for Sheff in the OF. What do y’all think?

I was rolling out Brett at 2B yesterday to finish the Event and he did admirably if you don't expect too much

@rosborn27 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

I was rolling out Brett at 2B yesterday to finish the Event and he did admirably if you don't expect too much

I got Biggio and Jackie tho for 2B right now.

Prestige Chipper?

I have similar lineup, I've been using prestige Sheff at 3rd because I can't take his bat out of my lineup. if a ball is hit crazy hard at him it can get by him, is the only problem I'm having lately w his D. usually a rocket

I’m a big fan of Brett! Play him at 3rd and Potm Thames at first. Been wanting to start Sheffield since I really don’t use him, and also going to buy Stan... tough decision...

3rd base and it's not even a question. That's where I've played Sheffield almost exclusively and I don't think I'll move him.

I agree tho on Prestige Sheff at 3B and actually have been running out Prestige Chipper at SS when I don't have Prestige Didi out there. Brett is nice but not on the offensive level as Sheff so just comes down to what you value more. For me, I live and die by the HR so I prefer power over defense when choices are close as I'm not that great a hitter so need all the power and contact that a hitter can give me.

I run Brett prestiged with both Chipper and Gary off the bench. I favor the vs RHP starter and he has enough power to go deep on any pitch as well.

As good as Brett’s swing is I use regular Sheffield. It turns out I mash with the dude. He also rarely makes errors

@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

I run Brett prestiged with both Chipper and Gary off the bench. I favor the vs RHP starter and he has enough power to go deep on any pitch as well.

I don’t know what it is but Brett hits a lot of home runs for me. Always hits frozen ropes. I just can’t take him out

@MLBTHEJOE said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

I run Brett prestiged with both Chipper and Gary off the bench. I favor the vs RHP starter and he has enough power to go deep on any pitch as well.

I don’t know what it is but Brett hits a lot of home runs for me. Always hits frozen ropes. I just can’t take him out

Higher contact=larger inside contact area means its easier to square balls up. Also has a sweet swing.

@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

@MLBTHEJOE said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

I run Brett prestiged with both Chipper and Gary off the bench. I favor the vs RHP starter and he has enough power to go deep on any pitch as well.

I don’t know what it is but Brett hits a lot of home runs for me. Always hits frozen ropes. I just can’t take him out

Higher contact=larger inside contact area means its easier to square balls up. Also has a sweet swing.

Yeah, I get bailed out by the maxed out vision/high contact he’s got lol. Also he’s got a sweet swing!

@MLBTHEJOE said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

@MLBTHEJOE said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

@ZFree1122 said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

I run Brett prestiged with both Chipper and Gary off the bench. I favor the vs RHP starter and he has enough power to go deep on any pitch as well.

I don’t know what it is but Brett hits a lot of home runs for me. Always hits frozen ropes. I just can’t take him out

Higher contact=larger inside contact area means its easier to square balls up. Also has a sweet swing.

Yeah, I get bailed out by the maxed out vision/high contact he’s got lol. Also he’s got a sweet swing!
Also me being trash and playing on all-star helps too hahaha

I would platoon them, I do a Brett and Killebrew platoon and I love both of their bats. Whoever isn't starting ends up being a badass bench bat

@Sayjinman said in Prestige Sheff or TA Brett at 3B?:

I’ll have Prestige Sheff soon and I’ve been using him at 3B with no real problems defensively so far. Been using TA Brett at 1B until I get Musial. Once I get Musial, who do I move to 3B? My OF is LF Mantle, CF Super Trout, RF Walker so there is no room for Sheff in the OF. What do y’all think?

I dont have TA Brett but I'm inclined to move my Sheff to 3B to put a better defender in RF (Potm Belli is my best option right now). I love Vet/Prestige Chipper but I think he may become a bench bat for me.

Main question is....who do you hit better with? Thats the guy who should be in your lineup as a starter. Use the other as a pinch hitter.